Gino's Pizza - Menu

1615 Dutch Broadway, Elmont, NY 11003, United States

🛍 Pizza, Cheese, Italian, Pizzeria

3.8 💬 304 Reviews

Phone: +15165616664

Address: 1615 Dutch Broadway, Elmont, NY 11003, United States

City: Elmont

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 304

"As someone who has been buying Gino’s pizza for over seven years, the change in quality of their pizzas has been disappointing to see over the past year. Their pizza used to be the best of the best but now their pies are tasteless. It’s like it was made with no salt, the sauce is thin and watery, and to top it all off they charge over FIVE dollars for pepperoni. I can’t justify spending my hard earned money here anymore when their prices have not only increased but their quality has significantly decreased. It is truly disappointing as someone who has been a fan for several years."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Pasta

Chicken

Pizza

Salads

Soups

Entrées

Calzone

Pizza - By The Slice

Dessert

Whole Pizza Pies

Ensaladas

Seafood

House Specialties

Chicken Dishes

Penne

Starters

Hot Subs

Salads &Amp;Amp; Sides

Fresh Seafood

Novaboba Novaboba

For two slices of cheese $7 something almost $8, did not buy.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

DARRYL
DARRYL

Good food and affordable but suggest ordering when you arrive instead of phone


Gary
Gary

Over priced, charging more than actual value. Recommend to NOT go there they will rob you.


Nandy
Nandy

The line is long, but it moves fast. I love to get the Buffalo chicken pizza and pepperoni pizza. There are many options available on the menu. The chicken salad is good, too. The staff are friendly and plenty of parking available. View menu


Ed
Ed

The best Pizza I have EVER had. And I've eaten a lot of pizza, all over the world. They are the best. By far. Whether it's cheese pizza, buffalo chicken pizza, their pasta, their calzones, their garlic knots....everything is exquisite. Well worth the price, and the wait.


Kadesha
Kadesha

It was very busy.. I went in to pick up my food and my garlic knots sauce was a mess it melted from being on the oven the one time I remembered to ask for sauce. I got a Sicilian pie which was great but garlic knots were a little brunt for my son. Not always like this but it is always busy. Parking: Handicap parking is right in front


Monique
Monique

I ordered a regular pizza today, and the bottom was burnt to the point that my children didn't want to eat it. I've been a loyal customer for over 20 years, and I can honestly say that the quality has significantly declined in the past year. Please be consistent with your food preparation. Every pizza should come out perfectly baked, not burnt. Thank you. View menu


N
N

Overall, this restaurant offers decent food. The sauce on the plain slice is a bit light, which makes it somewhat watery and runny in the end. However, the dough and cheese are enjoyable, and it’s baked thoroughly with a nice, crisp crust. I prefer to evaluate a pizzeria based on their plain slice, as it’s often a sign of their overall quality. If they have mastered the regular slice, they’re likely on the right track.


Judy
Judy

The salads here are absolutely amazing! The Special Salad is simply fantastic. And let's not forget about the calzones—they're baked and incredibly delicious! However, tonight I ordered the sausage and pepper hero, and I was let down. The bread was poorly assembled with the sausage and peppers just thrown in, and it looked quite unappetizing. This is definitely not typical of their usual quality, and I was really disappointed.


Sam
Sam

As someone who has been buying Gino’s pizza for over seven years, the change in quality of their pizzas has been disappointing to see over the past year. Their pizza used to be the best of the best but now their pies are tasteless. It’s like it was made with no salt, the sauce is thin and watery, and to top it all off they charge over FIVE dollars for pepperoni. I can’t justify spending my hard earned money here anymore when their prices have not only increased but their quality has significantly decreased. It is truly disappointing as someone who has been a fan for several years. View menu

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Cheese A curated selection of artisanal cheeses from around the world, featuring diverse flavors and textures that delight the palate. Perfect for sharing or savored individually with the ideal accompaniments. View menu
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!
  • Pizzeria Enjoy freshly baked pizzas with crispy crusts, savory sauces, and a variety of delicious toppings. Our pizzeria offers a wide range of traditional and gourmet options to satisfy all your cravings.

Amenities

  • Takeout
  • Parking Area
  • menu

Similar Restaurants

Prince Umberto

Prince Umberto

721 Franklin Ave, 11010, Franklin Square, United States

Menu • Pizza • Pasta • Italian • Seafood


"'FRESHER IS ALWAYS BETTER! Prince Umberto Pizzeria Restaurant 721 Franklin Ave, Franklin Square, NY 11010 Today 10/26/2023, I took my Honey for lunch for the first time to Prince Umberto 's in Franklin Square, NY. We both love good home made Italian food. I read some nice reviews, checked out their menu online and saw items we both like to eat, so to not far away Franklin Square we went! It was about 2;30 pm when we got there, the pizzeria side was busy but the dinning area side was wasn 't busy at all, and that 's exactly where we wanted to go. Our waiter and server Johnathan greeted us and sat us at a nice comfortable table. I ordered something for my Honey and I to drink, nothing with alcohol, while we looked over the menu. I told Johnathan we were going to first try a few appetizers, and after that, if we were still hungry we would order something else. I asked Johnathan, please, DO NOT bring us all the food at once, as so many other restaurants seem to want to do! All that food at once just overwhelms you, plus sitting there, the food just gets cold before you get to eat it. Johnathan said, not a problem, tell me what to bring you, and I will bring it when you tell me, YES! We started off first with Littleneck Clams on the half shell, then we had whole backed clams that were just made, nice and piping hot, and so, so, delicious. Next we enjoyed a nice size pot of mussels cooked with white wine and garlic, Johnathan brought us their just baked HOT pizza dough bread with butter on the side, it was excellent especially when we were dunking the bread into the mussel juice! After that my Honey and I had to try their Trippa Napoletana, we both love tripe! This tripe with the sauce made at Prince Umbertos was so good, my Honey had to take some home! It had no potatoes, no peas, just tender cooked tripe in a delicious mild sauce, which I was also enjoying on the hot pizza dough bread too. Just delicious. Wow! While were eating, the owner, and the chef came over to us a couple of times to ask if everything was okay and to our liking, and if we needed anything else, which was very nice of them to do. We now were both pretty full, but I had to check out their dessert menu first, before we left. I spotted their Italian ice cream Tartufo, and my Honey spotted the Tiramisu. We suddenly found a little space to tackle dessert, OMG! They both were so yummy! Now as far as prices go in this day and age of high prices, this restaurant has very, very, fair prices for quality fresh food! And I might add, this is one of the very few restaurants that is not charging any extra fee for using your credit card, I hope they can continue doing that, we shall see? We shall return for sure. Their food was so good, and freshly cooked to order, just as if we were home, it was a delight to go to Prince Umberto 's in Franklin Square today! Johnathan did an excellent job taking good care of us. And if I am going write an honest review, which I am, I have one wish, we both love clams on the half shell, ice cold. The clams on the half shell we had today were really fresh, but they were room temperature and not cold at all? I wish they can serve them ice cold, the next time we come. All in all, Prince Umberto 's still gets 5 stars! One tip for all, go for lunch or early dinner, You will have plenty of space in their dining room!"