Inn at Millrace Pond

313 Johnsonburg Rd BLAIRSTOWN, NJ 07825, 07825-3501, BLAIRSTOWN, United States

🛍 Venues, Cheese, American, Barbecue

4 💬 894 Reviews
Inn at Millrace Pond

Phone: +19084594884

Address: 313 Johnsonburg Rd Blairstown, NJ 07825, 07825-3501, BLAIRSTOWN, United States

City: BLAIRSTOWN

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 894

Website: http://www.innatmillracepond.com/

"I had been sent off by a few people because I LOVE prime rib. I had just heard great things about the restaurant. Unfortunately the whole experience was disappointing for us. We had reserved at the open table and requested a stand. When we got there, the hostess didn't confirm our reservation when we told her we booked them online and still got us to a table. She was our waitress and was pretty good. The drinks were well made but small for the price. We ordered the prime rib. I got the girls cut and my husband got the kings cut which is about a $ 20 difference in price. When they came out, they were exactly the smaller portion I ordered in length and thickness. We ordered medium rarity (which it came out like that), but it had no flavor and was extremely tough. If there's one thing I love almost as much as prime rib, it's ranch dressing. It was chunky and tasted terrible. (and no, it wasn't blue cheese) To get our USD 100 bill at the end of our meal, we were both utterly disappointed with the entire meal. The quality did not reflect the cost."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Start

Entrées

Dessert

Sharable's

Salads

Chicken Wings

Seafood

Sándwich

Beef Dishes

Side Orders

Starters

Specialties

Red Sauces

Passed Hors D'oeuvres

Second Course

Comfort

Main Dishes

Meat

Not Pizza

To Start

Individual Portions

Mains

Savion Savion

The food was great. We had the prawns and the chicken parm.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Bernhard
Bernhard

We go once a week. You can't beat the food or the service !!


Emmet
Emmet

The Inn at Millrace Pond I traveled into the area with a girlfriend.


Ila
Ila

Got married here 22 years agoWas great then and is still a 5 star place to eat, sleep and be merry. View menu


Gerardo
Gerardo

Server was incredibly rude. I never asked if we need to refill drinks. I never asked if the food was okay. Ordered a medium-rare prime rib. It came out medium good. My husband's middle rib was much rarer than mine. Just an overall bad experience.


Евангелина
Евангелина

As always, the highlight of the meal was the prime rib. That's the main reason I occasionally stop for dinner at Jerico's. The blue cheese salad dressing is so-so and tastes like it comes out of a glass, but the wine portions are quite generous, although the wine list is quite dated and conventional. And at 77, I just have to have qualified to reach the minimum age for entry! Still, the prime rib is the best in town.!


Alphonso
Alphonso

Going to this restaurant was a terrible experience. Our waitress was one of the worst I've ever had. We waited 15 minutes for drinks. When she finally came to take our order, she said she forgot her pen. She disappeared for another 20 minutes. The food was cold and tasteless. At one point my brother said my grandmother's steaks were better and that she was the worst cook in the family. To top it off, the waitress never came back with my change when I paid my bill, she pocketed it. If it had been more money I would have complained right away, but it was $ 8. View menu


Kolby
Kolby

The food was very good. However, the service was not. It was a while before we walked in and someone greeted us at the host station. Once greeted, we sat and then it took over 5 minutes for our waitress to contact us. We discussed getting up and going somewhere else when she got to our table. We ordered drinks and the wait began. We could see our drinks at the bar but again it took forever for the waitress to bring them to us. Overall, the only salvation for us that night was the food. It was very good. I had the prime rib and it was tops. I will try this again but was disappointed with the overall result mainly because of the lack of service.


Arden
Arden

Jerico's has been our point of contact for special occasions for years. Unfortunately this time has not fulfilled all of our previous experiences. Usually the fillets (Knight's Cut) are incredibly tasty and tender. This time they were barely seasoned and had to be sent back to reach the medium kitchen we requested. This information was shared with both the hostess and our server. While the hostess offered to put another steak on the grill, we didn't want that as it would have been wasteful as we wouldn't be able to eat it then and we couldn't eat it home in time. That being said, the only response / action was to say that you and our server are sorry. We will continue to recommend Jerico's,...


Janja
Janja

I had been sent off by a few people because I LOVE prime rib. I had just heard great things about the restaurant. Unfortunately the whole experience was disappointing for us. We had reserved at the open table and requested a stand. When we got there, the hostess didn't confirm our reservation when we told her we booked them online and still got us to a table. She was our waitress and was pretty good. The drinks were well made but small for the price. We ordered the prime rib. I got the girls cut and my husband got the kings cut which is about a $ 20 difference in price. When they came out, they were exactly the smaller portion I ordered in length and thickness. We ordered medium rarity (whic... View menu

Categories

  • Venues Distinctive spaces perfect for hosting any occasion, with stylish interiors and versatile layouts. Ideal for celebrations, meetings, or casual dining experiences, offering top-notch service and culinary delights to satisfy every guest.
  • Cheese A curated selection of artisanal cheeses from around the world, featuring diverse flavors and textures that delight the palate. Perfect for sharing or savored individually with the ideal accompaniments. View menu
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.
  • Barbecue Savor the smoky, juicy flavors of our barbecue delights. From tender ribs to succulent pulled pork, each dish is grilled to perfection with our signature sauces, offering a true taste of barbecue heaven.

Amenities

  • Beer
  • Wine
  • menu
  • Amex
  • menu
  • Takeout

Similar Restaurants

Inn At Millrace Pond

Inn At Millrace Pond

313 Johnsonburg Rd, BLAIRSTOWN, United States

Menu • Wine • Steak • Chicken • American


"We went for Mother’s Day. We were first to arrive and asked to wait while they had a staff meeting, which was ok since we were a few minutes early. After getting seated, while placing our order, we asked how the eggs were done with the steak and eggs. My wife was ok with poached, but asked for the sauce on the side. I asked for a substitution of poached for fried. When the dishes were delivered, several things were not as we ordered. When i stated these entrees were not as ordered, we were told “that’s how the chef serves it”. I wouldn’t have selected this had I been informed I wasn’t getting what I ordered. The steaks were tough, too well done and small. When a second staff person came over, she dismissed our concerns and told us “the chef does it all the same, we can’t have special orders with 200 meals”. Later the manager walked by, and told us he wasn’t charging for 1 of these. I told him I would have preferred to just get my order as expected and he also admitted the chef isn’t flexible. Apart from that, our daughter ordered chicken and waffles which were such a small portion she wad still hungry. The value is not in keeping with other options we are used to and the lack of attention to customer requests is really amazing. If the chef isn’t going to do it our way(is it really too much to ask to have the sauce on the side? then come and tell us and we will select another choice. The choices were very limited, the portions too small for the price and they didn’t try to make us feel like they were even willing to meet our needs. With plenty of other choices, we won’t return, and we were left with the impression they don’t even care. Not recommended, which is a shame since it’s close, very historic and has such potential."