Irish Eyes Pub - Menu

2956 US Route 9W, New Windsor, United States

🛍 Pub, Food, Pizza, Irish

4.6 💬 262 Reviews
Irish Eyes Pub

Phone: (+1)8455629867

Address: 2956 US Route 9W, New Windsor, United States

City: New Windsor

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 262

"Lives in the area for many years and has never been here. We stumbled over this last night (Sat) and took a chance bc we saw 5 star reviews. We went to a busy place, but fortunately Bar was open, and we enjoy bar seats. It was super busy, so we were glad to get a place and have a drink. It took awhile for food (no judgment here for a busy Sat Eve) and once it came, it was delish. French onion soup, coconut shrimp (better than most seafood pots) and French dip. All very good, my only complaint is that our bread was so beautiful for the French dip that it was gummy. But the flavors were so good. After seeing the menu, I can't wait to try other things... we will be back and cannot believe that it takes so long to find an amazing Irish pub!"

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Sandwiches

Entrées

Starters

Chicken Wings

Gyros

Main Courses

Meat Dishes

Specialties

Fish Dishes

Seafood

Soups

Seafood Specialties

Gluten Free

Appetizers

Salads

Wraps

Chicken Dishes

& More

Starters & Barfood

Lunch And Dinner

Wraps And Sandwiches

Buns

Oceanaire Classics

Pizza

Joelle Joelle

Food was delicious. Would give 5 stars if it wasn't so small.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Joelle
Joelle

We had the French onion soup, and the lobster bisque is incredible! You definitely need to try it!


Дана
Дана

Great place!! Clean!! Food is awesome!!! The bartender/waitress was also unbelievably awesome!! I will be back.


Oral
Oral

The menu is quite extensive, and both the food and service were excellent. I will definitely return in the near future. View menu


Dillon
Dillon

Stopped by at this pub with the family. We were pleasantly surprised that everything we ordered came out great. Exactly what we had hoped for.


Sylvia
Sylvia

All of it...Food, Service and Ambiance were excellent! Lady who waited on us was one of the best servers we've ever had, plus she was taking care of bar...


Lisa
Lisa

Lived in the area for many years and have never been here. We stumbled across this last night (Sat) and took a chance bc we saw 5 star reviews. We walked... View menu


Stephanie
Stephanie

Awesome welcoming bar pub. This is our go to spot for a casual date night. Or for catering wings for family events. When our kids friends visit we always...


Meta
Meta

Excellent service and food was delicious. I ordered a custom burger with bacon, horse radish cheddar and crispy onions. Best burger I had in a long time. Perfectly cooked. Both the burger and fries came out piping hot and burger was very juicy with nice char on the outside. Just the way I like it.


London
London

Lives in the area for many years and has never been here. We stumbled over this last night (Sat) and took a chance bc we saw 5 star reviews. We went to a busy place, but fortunately Bar was open, and we enjoy bar seats. It was super busy, so we were glad to get a place and have a drink. It took awhile for food (no judgment here for a busy Sat Eve) and once it came, it was delish. French onion soup, coconut shrimp (better than most seafood pots) and French dip. All very good, my only complaint is that our bread was so beautiful for the French dip that it was gummy. But the flavors were so good. After seeing the menu, I can't wait to try other things... we will be back and cannot believe that... View menu

Categories

  • Pub Enjoy a lively atmosphere with our classic pub favorites. From hearty burgers and fish 'n' chips to savory pies and craft brews, our menu promises a cozy experience ideal for unwinding with friends.
  • Food Delight in our diverse food selection, offering a blend of classic favorites and innovative dishes. Each item is crafted with the freshest ingredients to tantalize your taste buds and provide a memorable dining experience. View menu
  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Irish Authentic Irish cuisine offering hearty dishes rich in tradition. Enjoy our selection of classics like corned beef, stews, and soda bread, all infused with the comforting flavors of Ireland.

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Beer
  • menu
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Television

Similar Restaurants

Ms. Fairfax

Ms. Fairfax

105 Liberty Street, City Of Newburgh, 12550, United States Of America, City of Newburgh

Menu • Brunch • Casual • American • Breakfast


"tl;dr: awesome spot, reasonably-priced, delicious food, great service. wonderful neighborhood gem!we were debating btw this place and another spot, but this place ultimately won because i got drawn in by one thing and one thing only: the steak frites. the place was cozy and romantic, with a few tabled already occupied. they're currently offering an inflation buster prix-fix menu, for 1 app and 2 mains for $60 and that's what we went with. we got the following to try:-BBQ ranch chicken nachos: huge portion! juicy chicken breast strips, pico de gallo, ranch, bbq sauce, and melty cheese on crunchy tortilla chips. the pico had a nice tang to it, it wasn't your typical lime juice but i can't seem to put a finger on it. but really good! i do think it's better to cut the chicken into cubes than strips tho, for better chicken-to-nacho distribution ratio.-steak frites: comes perfectly cooked as requested (medium rare), served with bearnaise, fries, and garlic aioli. the steak was thick, meaty, and tender. the bearnaise sauce was awesome. we loved the garlic aioli and it paired well with the crispy fries. HIGHLY recommend this one!-brick chicken: seared, deboned half chicken (except the drumette, for presentation), served with baby potatoes, and mushroom/spinach in a marsala wine sauce. the chicken was nicely seared and juicy (yes, even the chicken breast), but a tad too salty for my taste. the marsala wine sauce was rich and creamy, but it does get a little heavy after a few bites.-lemon sugar crepe: light, tangy, refreshing.i also tried a cocktail but can't seem to remember the name of it for the life of me. i believe it was gin-based, with some kind of citrus. it was really tasty and well-balanced too. service was awesome, food was delicious, huge portions (we had leftovers), and just a really wonderful neighborhood gem. would love to stop in again if we're in the area!"

Liberty Street Bistro

Liberty Street Bistro

97 Liberty Street, 12550, Newburgh, United States

Menu • Bistro • French • Italian • American


"Have had this place on my radar for sometime took a chance and got a reservation for four at 8pm. With my name in the reservation book I begin to do some research on the chef, and also what was on the menu for the evening. Naturally the four courses was happening beginning with the beef tartare beautifully plated with an egg yolk quinelle of carrot pesto grain mustard and Dijon. Very delicate the meat basically melted as soon as it hit the tongue. Next course I ordered the butternut squash ravioli and Bronzino the sabayon was exactly what the doctor ordered to tie both the ravioli and Bronzino together. The rest of the group got the gnocchi which I described them as little pillows of potato heaven, not your ordinary dense dumplings, almost reminded me of gnudi I could have polished 3 bowls of them. For main I received the triple seared beef cooked perfectly nestled between a gratin and root vegetable. Dessert I received the three creme brûlée the almond was my favorite following the coffee than the green tea. I am glad to see this place in Newburgh such a beautiful setting as soon as you step into the restaurant it's unbelievable the ambiance and the true attentiveness of the waitstaff as well. For such a young chef truly a visionary and making notches in the culinary world of the Henson valley. Well done LSB one of my only critiques would be I don't drink doesn't mean I don't enjoy something with some personality, and distinguishing traits behind it. Will definitely be returning."