Jay's Deli

Address: 516 St Rte 32, Highland Mills, 10930, United States Of America

City: Highland Mills

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 76

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Pizza

Taco Pizza

A fusion of flavors with seasoned ground beef, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, and taco sauce on a crispy pizza crust.

Salad Pizza

A unique fusion with fresh greens, tomatoes, mozzarella, and a balsamic vinaigrette on a crispy pizza crust.

White Pizza

A savory pizza topped with a blend of rich cheeses and garlic-infused olive oil, no tomato sauce.

Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese pizza featuring a rich tomato sauce, gooey mozzarella, and fresh basil on a crisp, golden crust.

Sicilian Pizza

Sicilian Pizza: Thick crust, rich tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and a sprinkle of oregano, offering a hearty, traditional Italian flavor.

Sandwiches

Cheesesteak

A classic Philadelphia-style sandwich with thinly sliced beef, melted cheese, and sautéed onions on a hoagie roll.

Cold Heroes

Italian Heroes

Heroes

Entrées

Fried Ravioli

Crispy golden ravioli filled with cheese, served with a side of marinara sauce.

Jalapeno Poppers

Spicy jalapeños stuffed with creamy cheese, breaded, and fried to golden perfection for a zesty, crunchy appetizer delight.

...

Our Meals

World Famous Cold Heros

Salads

Caesar Salad

Crisp romaine lettuce tossed with creamy Caesar dressing, garlic croutons, and grated Parmesan cheese.

Calzone

Cheese Calzone

A warm, golden-baked calzone stuffed with a blend of gooey cheeses, offering a perfect savory delight.

Boar's Head Make It Your Own Sandwich

Cold Heros

Specialty Slice

Chicken

Buffalo Chicken

Spicy buffalo sauce draped over crispy chicken, served with a side of creamy ranch for a savory, tangy punch.

Savory

Breakfast Pizza

Savory breakfast pizza topped with eggs, cheese, bacon, and sausage on a crispy crust.

Side Orders

Heros (Lunch)

First Class Sandwiches

Whole Pizza Pies

Baked Ziti Pizza

A delicious fusion of baked ziti pasta and pizza, topped with rich marinara sauce, melted mozzarella, and hearty ziti on a crispy crust.

Mixed Salads

Address

Similar Restaurants

Mario's

➤ 503 State Route 32, Highland Mills, United States

Menu • Soup • Pizza • Coffee • Italian

"We had our rehearsal dinner here and we are so thankful we did! We were originally supposed to get married in March 2020 and Lisa was so wonderful with us postponing and rescheduling our wedding so many times. She was AMAZING! So easy to work with she made our event stress free. The staff were all so kind and the service was incredible no one was ever without a drink! So much food was included in the package it was all so delicious. We had 35 total people and everyone who came raved about how good the food was. We are so lucky we found Mario?s and can?t wait to be back again! Highly recommend if you need a place to host an event. Thanks for everything!"

A Better Place

➤ 200 Route 32 #3,4,5, Central Valley, Woodbury, New York, USA, 10917, United States

Menu • Pubs • Burgers • American • Delivery Services

"This bar isn 't called A better place for no reason, it really is a better place! right when you walk in the atmosphere is warm and inviting. The bartender Pattie has a welcoming and friendly aura that brings you in and makes you want to bring all your friends. Ive only been here a few times but her service is exceptional, she always caters to anything me or the people around me need in such a genuine caring manner. she really makes me feel seen, we usually end up chatting, catching up about our lives, laughing, talking on the beauty of life and the commonalities of being woman, seriously the best bartender I 've ever had, I come to the bar just to see her, Id consider her a friend at this point! don 't hesitate to come here if your looking for a good time, a few drinks or just... a better place."

➤ 534 State Route 32, 10930, Highland Mills, United States

Menu • Pizza • Delis • American • North American

"I have grown up with Jay's Deli. Colleen has always taken care of us for every special occasion and beyond! But recently we had a death in the family, and Colleen and her crew were able to accommodate us within the hour withcomfort food, dessert, etc. Bringing a smile to everyone's face. Thank you for making a very difficult time...easier."

Iron Chef Of Central Valley

➤ 365 NY-32, 10917, Central Valley, US, 10930, CENTRAL VALLEY, United States

Menu • Soup • Asian • Sushi • Chicken

"We have been here and taken out a number of times and each time the food is delicious. Tonight I had the Carribean Martini which was delicious, with the perfect level of sweetness and Caribbean flavors. For dinner, two of us had Drunken Noodles (YUM). One with chicken and the other with Tofu and both were so good, there was nothing left for a doggie bag. Someone else ordered the chicken Tempura platter which they thoroughly enjoyed and the fourth dish was shrimp teriyakiwhich was cooked to perfection. Great food at a local restaurant can't be beat. If you are in the mood for Japanese and /or Asian fusion dishes, give the Iron Chef a try!"

Grand Mango Caribbean

➤ 4 Smith Clove Rd, 10917, Central Valley, US, CENTRAL VALLEY, United States

Menu • Cheese • Catering • Jamaican • Caribbean

"As I walked from the car to the restaurant entrance, I could literally smell the jerk chicken sizzling away on a barbecue smoker in the back, and I was eager to dig in. They had oxtails on the menu, which I had to try, along with rice and peas—a staple dish. I inquired about sweet cabbage and plantains, and the young man behind the counter smiled and said, "Oh, so you know then?" Trust me, I know! For my fiancé, who is new to Caribbean cuisine, I suggested she play it safe. She went with fried chicken, jerked mac and cheese, and I recommended both cabbage and plantains as sides. I also ordered a beef patty. The food was incredible—totally legit and, most importantly, utterly delicious at a fantastic price. On weekdays, a small portion lunch meal (which was actually quite generous) includes your choice of rice and peas or mac and cheese, cabbage and plantains, plus your main dish and a drink—all for just $10! The interior could use some serious updating. It’s quite dated and the layout is a bit haphazard—more of a deli/lunch spot than a restaurant, and you can't order a sandwich or pick up sides for a picnic. It’s a little strange: folding tables and chairs, random posters on the walls, and nothing really matches. However, I’m not bothered by that at all—I’m here to eat, and a place like this doesn’t need to impress with décor; it needs to shine through its food, which it certainly does. If you are familiar with Caribbean cuisine, you’ll find this place to be the real deal. If you’re looking to try something new, definitely give it a shot. However, if you have very high standards for restaurants, or if spicy ethnic foods aren’t your thing, you might consider skipping it, but that would be a big mistake. Vegetarian options: I mean, have you ever experienced Caribbean food before? They put pork in their greens, for heaven's sake! Kid-friendliness: I suppose it’s kid-friendly, but it’s not as if there’s a ball pit in the corner or crayons on the tables. Parking: There isn’t a lot of parking available, but it shouldn’t be a problem. Wheelchair accessibility: Maybe from the back, but it’s not really ADA compliant. Still, once you catch a whiff of those spices, even if I were wheelchair-bound, I’d find a way to drag myself inside! Dietary restrictions: If you don’t like pork, beef, chicken, shrimp, or goat, or if you're not a fan of bold, spicy dishes, you might find it overwhelming—but trust me, the flavors are heavenly!"

Jay's Deli - Menu