Johnny's New York Style Pizza

I had a terrible experience at this restaurant, and it felt like a complete waste of money. The crust was doughy and tasted undercooked, while the toppings appeared to be haphazardly thrown on without being properly integrated into the slice. The salad was just as disappointing, with a dressing that lacked flavor and was overly watery. After not ordering from them for years, I can confidently say I won't be coming back!

The garlic knots, priced at $5.99, were a pleasant surprise. I expected maybe 6-8 knots, but we received about 20-25 in our order! We enjoyed them with the pizza and still had leftovers to serve with spaghetti the next night. Overall, I’m really pleased with Johnny's and happy they deliver to our neighborhood. The service was excellent, the pizza was delicious, and the garlic knots were plentiful. Although Johnny's isn't my top choice in the area, it is definitely climbing up my list!

Johnny's has always been my go-to for a great salad, but I had to deduct a star this time because the gentleman who took my order was a bit rude and short with me. Though I understand he was likely frustrated by the heavy traffic and being short-staffed, he hurried through my order and still managed to get it wrong! Come on, people—having good listening skills is key to receiving a positive review. My order was simple, and there was really no reason for errors. Other than that, everything else was good. View menu

The food is decent if you stick to the pizza, but the kitchen cleanliness is shocking. There’s a thick layer of flour dust caked onto the oven hood, obscuring the colorful stickers that used to be visible. The area where takeout orders are handed off has greasy handprints all over the surface. The kitchen has a monitor for watching TV that is also covered in food-related fingerprints. Additionally, the speakers playing the music are covered with half an inch of dust and cobwebs. This place is in desperate need of a deep cleaning. If this is what I can see, I shudder to think about what I can’t see. This last visit was the last straw for me. Absolutely disgusting.

I've been coming here for years. Just got a deluxe vege (Veggie Deluxe Pizza Onions, green peppers, mushrooms, fresh spinach, diced tomatoes, green black olives. and Bronx bomber with salad N Johnny's oil-vinegar herb and there is so much deliciousness in my tummy. Hey this is going to last for days, whadya think, I'm a pig? Get outta here. Gotta try the meatball sub! Ommm. And the getti sauce is momma mia, slap my momma good! Oh and gotta go with the fancy dancy The Gourmet Pizza! Bon Appetit! Fresh spinach, sun-dried tomatoes, black olives, artichoke hearts feta cheese. Yeah, I cut and pasted it, so what. Been in my tummy many times, that the only she likes. Me, love them all but the veggi...

Barely just ok. Arrived at 7:40pm to grab some dinner and the patio (front) door and back door are both propped wide open when it's 35 degrees outside. It's freezing inside the restaurant. Service was ok at best. Store is pretty dirty. Floors and tables are dirty. Menus have a LOT of dried on whatever on them. Dead bugs on the windowsill. Very dusty blinds,etc. When I mentioned about it being cold the server said it was because it gets smoky in the restaurant. Later I ask if they can close the doors bc all the guests in the restaurant (8 of us) are visibly cold. It's instantly warmer and instantly smoky. It shouldn't be this way. After 10 years in the restaurant business myself, they need to... View menu

After placing our order, we sat there for what felt like ages with no food or drinks. The waitress returned to our table, brought another menu, and asked for our order again. By this point, we had been waiting quite some time without receiving anything. Frustrated, I requested that our order be packed to go. This seemed to upset her, and she claimed that she hadn't entered our order into the system yet, even though we had ordered the same items three times. We expressed our dissatisfaction and decided to just forget about the order because she was continuously arguing with us over the situation. It wasn't an enjoyable experience having to reorder three times while she hadn’t even sent it to...

It 's not easy to get less than three stars from me. And the only reason Johnnys did not get 1 stars was because 1. I remember how good their pizza used to be and 2. The staff was very nice. My family has a house right across the street so I remember coming here when they first opened and it being so clutch. Fast forward 10 years, i now live in Brooklyn, NY so I know what authentic NY style pizza is. One of the most signature characteristics of a NY slice, is when you fold it at the crust, it keeps in shape up, doesn 't fall, and only the tip slightly hangs (maybe a little oil from the pepperoni drips : . This pizza could be nothing further, and should remove NY Style from their name. I orde...

Update: I was contacted by the company rep., Andy, who stated the owner would want to reach out and make things right. The owner never did reach out, and no compensation was given for such an inept service. I think perhaps, this was just an attempt to get me to change my rating or appear to care about the consumers experience. I placed an order for delivery a few hours in advance. The pizza was supposed to be delivered at 6:00. The order was delivered at 6:15 incorrectly. The girl working the counter sent the delivery driver to us with someone else's order. This store doesn't have it's own drivers, so it contracts out to DoorDash, even if you order directly from their website. I called the s... View menu