One if by Land, Two if by Sea

17 Barrow St. New York, NY 10014, 10014-6812, United States

🛍 Fish, Meat, Coffee, American

4.2 💬 9153 Reviews
One if by Land, Two if by Sea

Phone: +12122558649,+12122280822

Address: 17 Barrow St. New York, NY 10014, 10014-6812, United States

City: New York

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 9153

Website: http://www.oneifbyland.com/

"A “Gem” in the middle of lower Manhattan. Being that I’m a big fan of John Gotti, it was fitting to have dinner at this fabulous restaurant because this was his favorite restaurant according to his daughter, Angel. And in true fashion, we were not disappointed one bit. The ambience is absolutely spectacular and very romantic. We ate from the three course meal menu and everything was absolutely delicious. I highly recommend this place. Thank you, Angel Gotti for letting us know that this was one of your dad’s favorite restaurant in all of Manhattan."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Dessert

Starters

Entree

Toast

Soups

Mains

Rice

Sushi

Egg Dishes

Baked Specialties

Tuna Tartare

Dessert Menu

American Food

Featured Items

Family Meals

Brunch

Pantry Staples

Les Oeufs

Egg-Centric Dishes

Seafood

Seven Course Chef’s Tasting

Brunch Selections

Mains Pasta

Amparo Amparo

that was great. I wish a drink was a part of the 150.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Carleton
Carleton

the bark wellington was fantastic. great restaurant, good service.


Patrick
Patrick

Romantic restaurant but the food and service falls short of expectations


Opentable
Opentable

Unbelievably amazing! We were blown out of the water by everything food, service, accommodation. View menu


Derrick
Derrick

Great date night experience! We had the three course meal, but will definitely be back for the Chef’s tasting menu.


Chelsey
Chelsey

we spent here our jubilee and it was a wonderful experience. we will definitely be back for another special occasion.


Emmy
Emmy

I and my fiancée celebrated our 4 years jubilee here eating was excellently recommend the risotto, grilled otopus, and the bark wellington was great. amazing service just a bit expensive, more a social start location safe View menu


Tom
Tom

Disappointing. Service was great, ambiance was great, food was average at best .. certainly not worth the price . Check was delivered to the table and waiter asked us to leave immediately so that they could turn the table. Ink was barely dry on the check. I would not recommend .


Adam
Adam

Did not disappoint. I have been there several times in my life but not in a long time I have wanted to bring my wife for years I finally said we are going! We brought another couple that had never been either Everything was perfect! Fernando was awesome as was the rest of the staff! And of course, the WELLINGTON!! Thank you OIBL TIBS!!!!!


Chandra
Chandra

A “Gem” in the middle of lower Manhattan. Being that I’m a big fan of John Gotti, it was fitting to have dinner at this fabulous restaurant because this was his favorite restaurant according to his daughter, Angel. And in true fashion, we were not disappointed one bit. The ambience is absolutely spectacular and very romantic. We ate from the three course meal menu and everything was absolutely delicious. I highly recommend this place. Thank you, Angel Gotti for letting us know that this was one of your dad’s favorite restaurant in all of Manhattan. View menu

Categories

  • Fish Delight in our exquisite fish dishes, crafted from the freshest catch of the day. From grilled favorites to savory stews, our menu celebrates the ocean's bounty with flavors to satisfy every palate.
  • Meat Explore our mouth-watering meat selection, featuring expertly grilled steaks, tender chicken, and flavorful lamb dishes, each seasoned to perfection for an unforgettable dining experience. View menu
  • Coffee Indulge in our rich and aromatic coffee selection, expertly brewed to awaken your senses. From classic espresso to creamy lattes, discover the perfect blend to start your day on a flavorful note.
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.

Amenities

  • Beer
  • View
  • menu
  • Wine
  • menu
  • Amex

Similar Restaurants

Bread N Wine

Bread N Wine

1417 Lexington Ave, New York City I-10128-1613, United States

Menu • Wine • French • Coffee • American


"We went to Bread N Wine on a early Saturday afternoon for brunch. We were greeted and seated by the servers who were attentive. The food was okay the bread was really soft and fresh. My partner got the French Lentil Soup, Spinach and Tomato Egg Bake andI got the French onion soup, egg omelette with spicy tomato avocado and onions. I wasn 't happy with my omelette because thespicy just meant it was covered in hot sauce within. For beverages, we got chai lattes (we later found out it wasn 't tea basedbut rather coffee) and we had the option of oat milk, almond milk or regular milk. In terms of our overall experience we feltby the end too many things were steering the experience south; the worst was when we were accused of using counterfeit money topay for the tip. There was no special marker used to prove that the money was counterfeit or technology to back up this claim.That experience alone left a bad taste in our mouth as we left embarrassed by that claim, kind of shook from that, we stilladded the tip to our credit card 18%. As we walked out and talked about how weird that was, the owner of the business nextdoor overheard us and asked to see the $20 bill he showed us that our money was real and validated what we knew, that themoney wasn 't counterfeit. When we went back into Bread N Wine to discuss this there was no apology, just well, it felt thatway , shrug. It left a terrible feeling. We would not go back after that, this is not how you treat customers from start tofinish, hence the 2 star review."