Pony Grill And - Menu

The food is really good. Usually the service is so bad you can't fit it in for a normal lunch hours. It's very crowded, but the drinks are really tall.

We visited for their new family night where kids eat free. My husband ordered a Reuben, and halfway through, he discovered the longest, most tangled BLACK HAIR in it! We probably won't be going back again. How frustrating!

This was my first visit, and I'm so glad I came. Sheridan from Chicago, IL was our waitress, and she was fantastic! The food was amazing, and the terrace offered a wonderful atmosphere. The photos truly showcase just how great the food was here! View menu

Waited a while for a table, but the wait was well worth it! Large portions and good food. We enjoyed the atmosphere and found the staff to be friendly. Totally happy to see the free popcorn....: . This has been our best meal on this trip so far. Place attracts many locals, so must be one of the best eating spots in town.

we were not disappointed in the mood for a good burger and pony bar grill. we have the regular cheeseburger with tweebel rings. their wobble rings were huge. burgers were boiled medium that was perfect. so they were in doses, so no free refills, but we were in order. they also give a small discount when they pay with cash. we would definitely return.

The Pony has long been, and remains, the top spot for excellent food and outstanding service in Sheridan. While it can get quite busy at times, this is simply a testament to its popularity, not a fault of the service. The owners and wait staff are exceptionally friendly and accommodating, and the inviting atmosphere enhances the overall dining experience. View menu

I was reading some reviews about this restaurant, and one comment caught my attention—someone mentioned finding hair in their food and vowed never to eat there again. To be honest, this can happen at almost any restaurant. If you're that concerned, you might as well stay home and eat your own hair because chances are it could happen there too. We really love this place!

Great Wyoming Pub!. The first thing I noticed was how attentive the waitress are, drinks are never empty, salad or soup is almost immediately brought to you after you order, the food is fresh, fast and very good. During the summer the patio couldn't be more ideal. We never had to ask for extra anything, due to the handy little baskets at every table filled with anything you could want, mayo, mustard, relish and even miracle whip! I would recommend this to anyone.

Great Food!. My wife and I got stuck in Sheridan after hitting a deer on our trip through WY to the west coast. We had a few days to explore while our car was being fixed (thanks to Hammer's Collision) so we took the recommendations from some locals to try the Pony. My wife had a the Bronc burger with fries and i had their Triple combo (sandwich, salad, soup) Turkey w/ provolone and raspberry sauce, garden salad with honey mustard and their cream of Reuben soup. The food was excellent, the time for the food to come out was a little slow. Popcorn is their freebie in the restaurant. Good selection of beers on tap and in bottle. View menu