Buffalo Grill - Menu

501 Valley RdCO 81637, Gypsum, United States

🛍 Meat, Grill, Cheese, American

3.6 💬 105 Reviews

Phone: +19705240528

Address: 501 Valley RdCO 81637, Gypsum, United States

City: Gypsum

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 105

Website: https://buffalo-bar-and-grill.hub.biz

"The manager, bartender, hostess, and cook were all incredibly friendly, truly. However, a number of aspects of my experience were disappointing. I ordered the bison burger, which is the house specialty, cooked medium, but it arrived well done and extremely dry. The oversized slices of strong red onion on both the side salad and the burger were overwhelming. The fries were the highlight of the meal—fresh and not frozen—but they were spoiled by bottled dressings for dipping (bleu cheese and ranch). If you're going to hand-cut your fries, you should also make your own dressings. While the service was exceptionally sweet, receiving my bill handwritten on a small piece of notebook paper didn’t leave a great impression."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Sandwiches

Burger

Starters

Wraps

Chicken

L Hot Sandwiches

Salads

Dinners

La Villa Tradicional

Appetizer

Juicy Burgers & Co.

Handcrafted Burgers

Fish Dishes

American Food

Specialty Burgers

Soups

Hamburgers

Most Popular

Appetizers

Mexican Fiesta

Grant Grant

Had the Bison Burger.....OK at best!....Cool little spot!

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Madelyn
Madelyn

Avoid this place! They didn't have much on the menu, the soda was flat, and the jalapeño poppers were still frozen. The service was really slow too. The burgers were decent, but nothing to write home about.


Brian
Brian

This restaurant specializes in locally sourced bison and fresh produce. It’s a welcoming, family-run spot that’s ideal for enjoying a quick meal while catching a game in a warm, inviting setting. Additionally, they are open on Sundays, which is a bonus when many other places are shut.


Aja
Aja

I went to watch the game on Sunday with my family, and the food specials were outstanding. Don't just take my word for it—head over and experience the authentic, friendly atmosphere and fun bar games in Gypsum. We were looking for a great spot in the area, and this is definitely the one! View menu


Heidi
Heidi

We stumbled upon a charming little restaurant with a lovely hometown vibe. Our meals were absolutely delicious, and the portions were so generous that we had to take some home—definitely a place that ensures you won’t leave hungry! The waitress, owner, and locals were all extremely friendly. I’ll definitely be stopping by again on my next trip through. I give it a 5-star rating!


Chelsea
Chelsea

I stumbled across this place with my hubs and doggy. Sat on the patio. The gentlemen working was absolutely fabulous, welcoming, sweet, and great with my dog too! Our food was delicious!! I hat the buffalo burger and my husband had something else, but I remember being very pleased with both of our food! We both work in the hospitality industry so we know what to look for in both service and food! We found it here!


Burt
Burt

This restaurant has very peculiar hours. We’d love to swing by for a burger dinner someday, but it’s Saturday at 6 PM, and it looks like they’re already closed. I’ve heard great things about their breakfast burrito, but the sign clearly states it's a "bar and grill." Some reviews also mention that they sometimes run out of alcohol. I'm not entirely sure what's going on here, but they could definitely attract more customers if they had a clearer concept and more consistent hours. View menu


B
B

We stopped here for lunch during our road trip and were pleasantly surprised. While the restaurant could use some updates, the food was excellent. The side salad was very fresh, featuring high-quality greens instead of just iceberg lettuce, along with shredded carrots. The hamburger was outstanding—made with real meat, cooked to order, and well-seasoned. The French fries were irresistible, fresh-cut and perfectly cooked. The portions were generous, and the service was attentive. Don't let the appearance fool you!


Jelena
Jelena

We decided to visit this restaurant after seeing their advertisement in the window claiming they serve the best bison burger. However, when we tried to order the burgers, we were informed that the meat for the day hadn’t arrived yet. So, we opted for the Grilled Ham and Cheese and the Steak Wrap, each with a side of fries. The waiter mentioned that we could choose another side since two sides came with the meal, but we had to repeat our preference for just fries a couple of times. Overall, the food was enjoyable, but the condiment containers (mustard, ketchup, pepper, salt) were quite sticky and could use a good cleaning.


Lori
Lori

The manager, bartender, hostess, and cook were all incredibly friendly, truly. However, a number of aspects of my experience were disappointing. I ordered the bison burger, which is the house specialty, cooked medium, but it arrived well done and extremely dry. The oversized slices of strong red onion on both the side salad and the burger were overwhelming. The fries were the highlight of the meal—fresh and not frozen—but they were spoiled by bottled dressings for dipping (bleu cheese and ranch). If you're going to hand-cut your fries, you should also make your own dressings. While the service was exceptionally sweet, receiving my bill handwritten on a small piece of notebook paper didn’t le... View menu

Categories

  • Meat Explore our mouth-watering meat selection, featuring expertly grilled steaks, tender chicken, and flavorful lamb dishes, each seasoned to perfection for an unforgettable dining experience.
  • Grill Succulent meats and fresh vegetables perfectly cooked over an open flame, delivering rich smoky flavors. Savor tender steaks, juicy burgers, and tangy marinated kebabs, all grilled to perfection for an unforgettable dining experience. View menu
  • Cheese A curated selection of artisanal cheeses from around the world, featuring diverse flavors and textures that delight the palate. Perfect for sharing or savored individually with the ideal accompaniments.
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.

Amenities

  • Takeout
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Television
  • menu
  • Outdoor Seating

Similar Restaurants