Jimmy's Ice Cream - Menu

Biggest ice cream cones ever!! Great steak sandwiches and love the heart attack burger lol. Such a fun place to visit

Jimmy's is a fixture in the area, and their ice cream has been making people happy for a long time. The line is usually quite long, but it's 100% worth the wait.

Such a wonderful local ice cream shop! It has a lot of options in their menu from ice cream to food. My dog also loves their pup cups. Only downside is it's cash only so if you forget you're out of luck. View menu

I've been a customer at Jimmy's for over 30 years, and their soft serve ice cream has always been made with Welch Farms. However, when I visited for the first time this year in 2023, I was quite disappointed. The ice cream was overly airy and lacked flavor.

My wife and I visited for the first time yesterday, and our experience was absolutely fantastic. The restaurant was bustling with customers, but the line moved swiftly. The staff was friendly, and I highly recommend trying the cookie jar sundae! We’re looking forward to checking out their mini golf soon!

A summer tradition and a slice of nostalgia, Jimmy 's is a great local 'joint ' serving up good food and of course ice cream. The only bad think about is that they close down for the colder months and have to explain to my 4 and 2 year old when we pass by that it is closed....every day.....until it opens again. : View menu

best food ice cream anything you can buy in this little area. dont waste yer time in milford paying for some overpriced burger or a terrible desert. this place only comes around for this time of th w year do thw right thing and eat good. aside note: all of the workers are friendly and they got their system down. kudos to them

This place has 5 stars for good reason! I had been wanting to go here for a while, as it keeps winning Hunterdon Happening's best ice cream. Now I get it! I just got a small twist in a cone, but it was creamy and delicious! Just perfect on a hot summers day. My aunt ordered the peanut butter sundae and it was thick and yummy too! I love the old fashioned style of the place and how friendly everyone is. Will definitely be back to try more!

There’s a clear reason for the long wait times here, and it has nothing to do with the ice cream. The staff at Jimmy’s is extremely disorganized and fails to deliver accurate orders. The time it takes to place your order is quite lengthy, and the loud music makes it difficult to hear the server or even communicate with your own group. I ordered two simple ice creams: vanilla and pistachio, both in cups with lids (despite the vast selection of flavors advertised on their boards, the only ones available were strawberry, vanilla, pistachio, and chocolate). When my order was ready, it was handed to me separately at the pick-up window: the vanilla ice cream came in a paper bag (which was confusin... View menu