Killmeyer's Old Bavarian Inn

4256 Arthur Kill Rd, 10309, Staten Island, United States

🛍 Pubs, German, Bavarian, American

4 💬 2708 Reviews
Killmeyer's Old Bavarian Inn

Phone: +17189841202

Address: 4256 Arthur Kill Rd, 10309, Staten Island, United States

City: Staten Island

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 2708

Website: http://www.killmeyers.com

"I had the spicy beef goulash soup and a carving combo, while the rest of my party ordered brisket, a bratwurst combo, and a beef dish. The portions were generous and we had to pack some of the food to take home. We also ordered two beer samplers - one domestic and one imported, with different varieties. Yolanda and our waitress explained each beer to us before we made our selections. The atmosphere was pleasant with warm bread and butter served at our table. Everything we tried was delicious and we left feeling satisfied. The bill for the four of us, including the soup and two beer samplers, came to $122.50 before tip, which was very reasonable. It was my first time dining here and I will definitely be back. On a scale of 1-10, I would rate this restaurant a 20 for anyone looking for authentic German food. It was a fantastic experience and I highly recommend checking out their beer garden as well."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Sandwiches

Additional Offerings

Salads

Entrées

Chicken

Starters

Appetizers

Fish Dishes

Pizza

Grill Specialties

Lunch - Starts At $22

Beer Garden Pig Roast Bbq

Saturday & Sunday Only

Soups

Additional Fare

Specials

Dessert

Burger

Schnitzel

Pasta

Cutlet

New York Styles

Handhelds

SeanS SeanS

This restaurant with a German theme is fantastic. I have visited many times.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

User
User

If they are American, the food seems exotic and authentic, but if they are German or Bavarian, it is less so. The dining experience is not even satisfactory.


User
User

I recently had dinner with a friend who absolutely loves this restaurant. The beer menu was impressive, the staff was friendly and attentive, and we both enjoyed a pint of Cigar City Florida, which was quite nice.


User
User

This restaurant is a fantastic spot to unwind and savor genuine cuisine as well as a wide selection of beers. My band, Quartet of Catastrophe, will be performing there. It is hands down the top venue for its outdoor stage and welcoming staff. View menu


Dawn
Dawn

We had a very relaxing evening at the restaurant. We ordered drinks and a large pretzel while listening to a band play in the outdoor area. It was very enjoyable and we had a great time. The food was excellent, we give it a 5 out of 5 rating.


Natalia
Natalia

This is the place to go for great German food! It’s interesting decorating inside and out too. The service was okay. If you’re looking for beer, then this is also a great place to get one. We tried a sausage platter and it was tasty! For the next time I will try pretzel and potato pancakes, someone said we must try this) On Friday night there was a live music performance. It was very pleasant to listen to popular hits and it added a good impression on the atmosphere in this restaurant.


Rick
Rick

I was pleasantly surprised by the delicious food at this restaurant. In the past, the sauerbraten was tough and dry, but this time it was excellent. The waitresses were dressed in casual attire, rather than their usual traditional German outfits. I also noticed that none of the waitresses spoke German, which was a departure from the past. The owner mentioned that they are trying to sell the restaurant and move to Florida, which is evident from the low number of customers on a Friday night. It's sad to see it go, but I wish the owner a happy retirement. View menu


Mark
Mark

Popped in for a mid week dinner and a beer with a buddy. No waiting, seated right away. Beer is always on point here. Food was good, could've been a little warmer, but still tasty. Glad I skipped an app, because I could barely finish my entre.Vegetarian options: On the menu are vegetarian dishes.Kid-friendliness: It's like being at Pinochio's in Disney World. Without the yodelling music. You really do feel tranported to another part of the world.Parking: There's a couple up front, and some on the side. But across the street is a huge dirt lot that handles the overflow parking on the weekends and Summer.


User
User

Barely edible. The waitress never checked on how the appetizer was during . Walked by and picked up my app plate without a word. It was decent so fine The main course veal schnitzel came with an unedible pile of mush noodles that tasted like yesterday ramen. The schnitzel itssef was barely edible and i was hoping to drown it in mashed potatoes figuring they arent making things to order anyway, and how bad could that be but she never came back so i choked them down after a while and after 15 min she finally decided to stop by to collect my plate again without inquiry of how the food was. I guess she knows it's terrible and i got my check. Barely made it to the front door before my stomach sen...


User
User

I had the spicy beef goulash soup and a carving combo, while the rest of my party ordered brisket, a bratwurst combo, and a beef dish. The portions were generous and we had to pack some of the food to take home. We also ordered two beer samplers - one domestic and one imported, with different varieties. Yolanda and our waitress explained each beer to us before we made our selections. The atmosphere was pleasant with warm bread and butter served at our table. Everything we tried was delicious and we left feeling satisfied. The bill for the four of us, including the soup and two beer samplers, came to $122.50 before tip, which was very reasonable. It was my first time dining here and I will... View menu

Categories

  • Pubs "Discover a cozy atmosphere with hearty meals, craft beers, and classic pub fare. Enjoy comfort food favorites like fish and chips, burgers, and wings, paired with a refreshing pint or creative cocktail."
  • German Savor the rich flavors of traditional German cuisine, featuring hearty meats, tangy sauerkraut, and sumptuous sauces. Delight in authentic dishes that bring a taste of Germany to your table. View menu
  • Bavarian Traditional Bavarian delights offering hearty and flavorful favorites such as sausages, schnitzels, and pretzels, paired with tangy sauerkraut and creamy mashed potatoes, bringing you the rustic taste of Bavaria.
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Live Music
  • menu
  • Television

Similar Restaurants