Maxie's Supper Club Oyster

Ithaca, NY 14850, 635 W State St, United States,

🛍 Bars, Pubs, Catering, American Cuisine

4.5 💬 385 Reviews

"Our first time at Maxie's left us wanting to dine in again, so we made a reservation the very next day! We highly recommend the Pimm's cup for drinks, the oysters were fresh, the gumbo was delicious (next time I will be ordering the dinner portion), the jambalaya was huuuge — for my taste I'd add a little more finishing salt and a little more spicy kick to it, the arugula salad was yummy -especially with the cider dressing and dried cherries, the portabello mushrooms was yummy, and lastly the ca … – show"

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Entrées

World Famous House-Made Tater Tots

Vegetarian Options

Soups

Side Dishes

Fish Dishes

Saranac Brewery

Counter Meals

Lights

Gumbo Soups

Salads

Extras

Chicken

Starters

Fries & Sides

Main Attractions

Raw Bar

Ribs

Artisan Burgers (Certified Angus Beef®)

Heroes

Soul-Stirrin' Specialties

Sandwiches

Jambalaya

Specialties

Ranch House Specialty Plates

Proteins

Appetizers

Maxie's Soul-Stirrin' Classics

East Coast Oysters & Gulf Shrimp

Kevin Kevin

The Jabalaya was great, staff friendly and helpful.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

itsme
itsme

Always a fun atmosphere, and amazing food. Definitely make reservations!


Anna
Anna

In 21 years of dining at Maxie's I've never had a bad meal. They always do it right.


Gueorgui
Gueorgui

Food was alright, nothing particularly special. We went here because other restaurants were full that Friday night. View menu


Marie
Marie

Happiest happy hour fo sho! Raw bars amazing. Tuna dinner was delicious. Get the banana pie! Friendly fun happy experience


Denene
Denene

Loved the servers so upbeat and happy! Food was great, the special appetizer of rock shrimp was sweet and delicious. I had the special ruby trout and it was delicate and tender. My daughter had the chicken fried chicken and it was great comfort food!


Thomas
Thomas

Visiting the area for the weekend and I’m glad we stopped here! If you like seafood packed with tons of flavor, then this is your place! Food was delicious and the service was top notch. Be sure to make a reservation ahead of time as you will need one. Highly recommend. Great spot! View menu


Brittany
Brittany

Absolutely fantastic! We visit Ithaca a few times a year but it’s been a few years since we have been back to Maxies. I wish it didn’t take that long! Everything was delicious. I know how much the restaurant industry is suffering right now but it was a job well done here. Can’t wait to come back for some delicious seafood!


Jae
Jae

The food was ok, might’ve been better if it wasn’t cold. Wished our server knew what she was doing. She appeared to mean well but was very inexperienced. Forgot our cocktails and blamed the bartender saying she lost our tickets, refilled water upon request only to my husband although all of our glasses were empty, forgot our entrees and they came out cold, forgot lemons that we asked for — for our oysters, and left us a stack of clean plates to share our entrees after we finished…


Vallarie
Vallarie

Our first time at Maxie's left us wanting to dine in again, so we made a reservation the very next day! We highly recommend the Pimm's cup for drinks, the oysters were fresh, the gumbo was delicious (next time I will be ordering the dinner portion), the jambalaya was huuuge — for my taste I'd add a little more finishing salt and a little more spicy kick to it, the arugula salad was yummy -especially with the cider dressing and dried cherries, the portabello mushrooms was yummy, and lastly the ca … – show View menu

<a href

<a href

A cosmopolitan city, Atlanta blends Southern charm with urban culture. Known for its diverse food scene, typical dishes include fried chicken, peach cobbler, and juicy barbecue ribs.

Categories

  • Bars Discover our selection of expertly crafted cocktails, refreshing beers, and our curated list of fine wines. Perfect for unwinding with friends or pairing with your favorite dishes from our menu. Cheers!
  • Pubs "Discover a cozy atmosphere with hearty meals, craft beers, and classic pub fare. Enjoy comfort food favorites like fish and chips, burgers, and wings, paired with a refreshing pint or creative cocktail." View menu
  • Catering Catering services offering a diverse range of delicious and beautifully presented dishes, perfect for any event or gathering. Our menu combines creativity with quality ingredients to delight your guests.
  • American Cuisine American cuisine offers a diverse menu featuring hearty classics like burgers, fried chicken, and BBQ alongside vibrant salads, indulgent desserts, and innovative twists on traditional favorites.

Amenities

  • Wine
  • Beer
  • menu
  • Outdoor
  • menu
  • Live Music

Similar Restaurants