Natalie's Pizzeria - Menu

1312 Commonwealth Ave, Boston, United States Of America, 02134

🛍 Pizza, Greek, Italian, Chicken

2.6 💬 2528 Reviews
Natalie's Pizzeria

Phone: +16172777662

Address: 1312 Commonwealth Ave, Boston, United States Of America, 02134

City: Boston

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 2528

Website: https://www.nataliespizzeriama.com

"STAY AWAY. Ordered from here on Uber Eats to end up being completely scammed. Ordered alfredo chicken fettuccini, a cheeseburger with all toppings, and two soda cans. Ended up receiving some random pasta dish that tasted like raw tomatoes, no garlic bread when it said it’s included, a burger with nothing but a patty in two buns (not even cheese when its a cheeseburger), the burger came with 10 tiny short leftover fries and onion rings, and no sodas. DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE. If they respond to this review they’ll probably just say something like sorry and not do anything about it because half of their reviews are clearly all one stars. Once again, DO NOT EAT FROM HERE."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Salads

Pizza

Sandwiches

Entrées

Calzone

Baked

Cold Subs

Subs

Hot And Cold Subs

Mains

Stone Oven Pizza

Vegetarian Subs

Fried Potatoes

Mixed Basket

Steak Subs

Pizza - Mini Ø 20Cm

Subs & Wraps

Suggested Favorites Pizza

Pasta

American Food

Filled Pastas

Chicken Dishes

Marissa Marissa

I enjoyed the pizza and the service as well. It was a blessing on our trip.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Jay
Jay

The Pizza was the absolute best i’ve had a very long time. I had the Buffalo chicken pizza and I don’t usually make reviews but it was so good i had to leave one.


maple
maple

This place needs to be reported. They don’t close anywhere near 3:30 am. They were closed at 10:45 pm when I went. If you don’t open late then don’t post that you do


Han
Han

Pizza was cold. I’d give it 3 stars if it was warm but even so the pizza was mediocre. The only reason I don’t give it one star is because it’s open until 2am on a Saturday. View menu


M
M

I literally got 2 cakes when I ordered 2 large pizza after waiting for 3 hours. Dont ever get food from here they will make you wait for hours and wont even give you your food.


Sanath
Sanath

I have only tried the Veggie/Cheese Pizza each time I’ve been here and I gotta say the taste is exquisite. The Pasta with the Alfredo Sauce was quite good as well. I’d say if you are looking for an extremely late night meal, look no further thanNatalie’s.


Jon
Jon

We ordered a sandwich and a quesadilla. The sandwich was incredibly dry, lacking any sauce at all. The quesadilla, which was supposed to come with sour cream and salsa, didn't have either. The tortilla was poorly cooked and also didn't include the chicken we had requested. View menu


Brooke
Brooke

I was disappointed with my order tonight. I placed an order through Uber Eats and received a cold Italian sub and a cheesecake dessert. The menu indicated that the Italian sub comes with oil and vinegar, but there was no dressing, leaving it quite dry. Additionally, I was given a chocolate cake instead of the cheesecake I ordered.


Danaé
Danaé

I ordered Alfredo through DoorDash but received pasta with chicken and marinara sauce instead. When I called the restaurant, I was told I was speaking to a manager, who informed me that they didn’t have all the ingredients for fettuccine Alfredo, so they sent me this instead. It turns out I wasn’t actually speaking to a manager, and they just hung up on me. I recommend checking with them to ensure they have all the items on their menu before placing an order.


Ethan
Ethan

STAY AWAY. Ordered from here on Uber Eats to end up being completely scammed. Ordered alfredo chicken fettuccini, a cheeseburger with all toppings, and two soda cans. Ended up receiving some random pasta dish that tasted like raw tomatoes, no garlic bread when it said it’s included, a burger with nothing but a patty in two buns (not even cheese when its a cheeseburger), the burger came with 10 tiny short leftover fries and onion rings, and no sodas. DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE. If they respond to this review they’ll probably just say something like sorry and not do anything about it because half of their reviews are clearly all one stars. Once again, DO NOT EAT FROM HERE. View menu

Boston

Boston

Boston, known for its rich history and academic institutions, is famous for clam chowder, lobster rolls, and baked beans. The city's coastal charm blends with its vibrant cultural scene.

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Greek Savor the rich flavors of Greece with our authentic selection of traditional dishes. Delight in fresh ingredients, aromatic herbs, and classic recipes that bring the essence of the Mediterranean to your table. View menu
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!
  • Chicken Succulent and savory, our chicken dishes are crafted with tender meat, flavorful seasonings, and diverse culinary inspirations. Enjoy a delectable variety that's sure to satisfy every palate.

Amenities

  • Debit
  • Takeout
  • menu
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Television

Similar Restaurants

Souper Roll Up Cafe

Souper Roll Up Cafe

726 Cambridge Street Cambridge, MA 02141, United States

Menu • Cafe • Cafés • American • Sandwiches


"No soup/sandwich shop compares in terms of price per quality, portion size, and different options in the area. I only started ordering from here about 2 weeks ago and I’ve now had 7 different kinds of soups and 4 different kinds of sandwiches after the first order I started ordering two soups and a sandwich aka a soup to save for later because they’re just that good, every one of them. Price is so very reasonable and depending on which combo you get you can make out with a full sized sandwich and large sized homemade soup for $14.While it’s hard to recommend one thing over another in this circumstance since it’s all been great in their own ways, the Chicken Chowder is something I plan on getting a quart of next time it’s available. The Chicken Barley and Chicken Lemon Rice are ones I plan on getting quarts of in the future as well, and that’s not to discount the Chicken Noodle, Beef and Veg Noodle Stew, French Onion, and the current seasonal Chilled Gazpacha (which I probably wouldn’t have even tried it wasn’t from these guys . It’s all top quality.The Chicken Tarragon sandwich is my favorite in terms of sandwiches although it can’t combo with a soup as of now (please let us! . The best cheap soup combo sandwich is a tossup between the Cilantro Tuna and Ciabatta Sandwich, which are both incredible in their own ways.The only few drawbacks to this place are they don’t have every soup they make every day, are only open until 4PM, and aren’t open on the weekends. That said it’s worth it to plan accordingly for this. I never review anything but this place is worth it it’s the best if you’re a soup and sandwich person like I am."