Pizzaiolo Eatery - Menu

118 County Rd 4, 118 Commack Rd, Commack, NY 11725, USA, United States

🛍 Pizza, Salad, Lunch, Italian

4.6 💬 1212 Reviews
Pizzaiolo Eatery

Phone: +16314869300

Address: 118 County Rd 4, 118 Commack Rd, Commack, NY 11725, USA, United States

City: Commack

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 1212

Website: http://pizzaioloeatery.com

"We used to frequent this pizza restaurant before moving out of state. Although we love where we live now, we often think back to Long Island when we crave some delicious pizza. The quality of their pizza is outstanding, with a variety of flavors to choose from. Their Ciabatta sandwiches are also worth trying, particularly the one with Broccoli rabe, which can be a bit greasy at times but still delicious. The portions are generous, so come hungry. The house salad is also a favorite of mine. On Tuesdays, they have a special where you can get an 18-inch regular pizza for $12. The restaurant is clean, and the food is consistently good. I really miss this place."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Salads

Soups

Pasta

Entrées

Pizza

Sandwiches

Chicken

Signature Pasta Dishes

Gourmet Pizza's

Seafood

Penne

Meat Dishes

Al Forno*

Lunch Combos

Hot & Cold Heroes

Chicken Dishes

Vegetarian Dishes

Side Orders

Starters

Noodles

User User

Consistent the best pizza in Commack! I tried them all, and these are the hands down the best. Your regular menu is huge and the food is excellent.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

User
User

John. Thank you for always taking care of me, my friends and family when we come to your restaurant. Your food is always great and the prices are always fair. Keep the big work Bud!


User
User

John and his staff are awesome. Best pizza around. John has bailed me out of last minute food needs for unexpectedly company. He's a true professional. Never had anything bad here!!


User
User

This restaurant has the best variety of pizza I have ever seen! When I went on a Friday at noon, I saw 27 different types of slices available. If you're not counting calories, you can't go wrong here. Keep up the good work, guys! View menu


User
User

This is hands down the best pizza and Italian takeout spot in the Commack-Dix Hills area! My only complaint is that they should add an extra telephone line as it can be difficult to get through during peak hours. The sauce, dough, specialty slices, and entrees are exceptional! We frequently order catering and takeout from here and it always exceeds our expectations.


User
User

I am pleased to write this 5-star review. This facility is proud of its customer service, the quality of food and most of my expectations. I've been ordering pizzaiolo for about a year. Your food is delicious, my family and I love it. Prices are reasonable, their menu has many options and they are a local little business. I support these 5 stars. And my daughter loves her sauce and enjoys dinner with Daddy lol.


User
User

We used to frequent this pizza restaurant before moving out of state. Although we love where we live now, we often think back to Long Island when we crave some delicious pizza. The quality of their pizza is outstanding, with a variety of flavors to choose from. Their Ciabatta sandwiches are also worth trying, particularly the one with Broccoli rabe, which can be a bit greasy at times but still delicious. The portions are generous, so come hungry. The house salad is also a favorite of mine. On Tuesdays, they have a special where you can get an 18-inch regular pizza for $12. The restaurant is clean, and the food is consistently good. I really miss this place. View menu

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Salad A delightful assortment of vibrant salads, featuring fresh greens, seasonal vegetables, and savory toppings, drizzled with our signature dressings for a refreshing and wholesome meal experience. View menu
  • Lunch Satisfy your midday cravings with our delicious lunch menu. From fresh salads and hearty sandwiches to savory soups and vibrant bowls, each dish is crafted to give you the perfect midday boost.
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!

Similar Restaurants

Sangria 71

Sangria 71

1095 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, 11725, United States Of America

Menu • Tapas • Spanish • Seafood • Desserts


"UPDATE June 30, 2023 My family took another shot at Sangria 71 in Commack. Unfortunately, it was basically the same experience. Really great service. However, I was hoping that the food was just as good. However, it was once again average. The staff was outstanding. Our server Teresa was fantastic and went above and beyond to make our experience the best it could be. In addition, our busgirl Claudia also very pleasant. The hostesses were very accomadaing, and the valets were terrific. Alexi was also awesome! As for the food, my boil was good, but the shrimp was overcooked....very tough. However, the lobster was very tasty. The calamari was also good. The feedback on the steaks was mixed. The main criticism was not taste, it came down to the toughness of the meat. The desserts were good, but they did have ab artificial taste time them. It is a very nice restaurant aestetically, and it has a great vibe and energy. I really enjoyed the overall experience and want to like it more....they just need to kick up the food a notch....I hope that they do! ________________________________ A real solid 3 Stars. If I could give it 3.5 Stars I would; but there isn't that option for this review. This is a very nice space with a wonderful staff. Our waiter Aaron was terrific and our busgirl Teresa was fantastic! I wanted to rate this higher, but the food was a mixed bag. The oysters looked beautiful, but actually lacked flavor. I don't know how that's possible, but they were extremely bland. Not even a trace of the ocean...very odd. The salad had no flavor. It was very cold and basic. It reminded me of those salads in the NYC theater district resteraunts that are pre made and kept in the refrigerator. The octopus was good. Nice garlic flavoring. A little chewy, but good. My main course was tasty as well. I enjoy the seafood and flavors in the Mariscos. The Sangria was average; but I did enjoy the spicy Margherita very much. Our family enjoyed the desserts. Overall, it's a good place. It just needs to tweak a few things, and it can reach the next level."