Sexton's Pizza - Menu

Best Pizza in Columbus. Hands down. Owners are great people. Staff is always friendly and kind. Never disappoints.

I live in Cleveland, but a friend recommended I try the Kevin Bacon pizza while I was visiting. It's an excellent pizza!

Had Sextons on Tuesday, didnt have a good first time experience. They messed up one of my pizzas , so they remade it, by the time I got home my other pizzas were cold and the pizza was so so. They were friendly though. From the pics I've seen , I expected a little more. Might try them again, maybe they was just having a day. View menu

This is some of the best pizza I've had in awhile. I went in for pickup, but looks like a decent place to dine in. The staff was friendly, got our order perfect, was an all around good experience. Oh yeah, also: Their thick crust pie is on point. Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Features Dine in: Yes, Takeout: Yes

First time here and did online order for takeout. You get a 10% off with online ordering! I ordered two slices of pepperoni pizza, their Italian salad which was filled with fresh veggies onions green peppers romaine lettuce carrots and the Italian salad dressing was in a separate container which is preferable), and side appetizer of fried pepperoni which came with ranch dressing for dipping). These were amazing and very contagious, we couldn't stop eating them! The pizza had a delicious sauce with lots of pepperoni and the crust was more on the thin side and was stiff not doughy). It was yummy ! Looking forward to going back .

The pizza here is superb. I absolutely loved the crust. The candied bacon is sweet and very tasty, and really stands out, flavor-wise. The BLTC pizza is drizzled with their house made ranch dressing, which they also sell by the jar, it's that good. The spicy queso is on the menu as a side dish, and I was expecting bread to dip in queso. But it's really a pizza with queso sauce and fresh jalapeño peppers. It's amazing, and I'm not complaining, but it's definitely not what I though it would be. So we ended up with three pizzas and were so stuffed I thought I was going to have to be rolled out the door. One thing I also really appreciated, is that the women's bathroom has a shelf to put your ce... View menu

This is a fantastic little pizza place! They offer amazing appetizers (definitely try the garlic fries; you won't regret it) and have some really creative pizza options. We've sampled several of their pizzas, and we've enjoyed every one. The only reason I'm not giving a full five stars is that their pizza selection tends to lean more towards unique flavors rather than traditional ones. When we're in the mood for classic toppings, we usually head to one of the other pizzerias in town. The service is always friendly, and I've really appreciated their curbside pickup option during the pandemic. Parking is easy and plentiful. The interior looks charming in the pictures, but I won't have a chance...

One of the most awful restaurant experiences I 've had in the last couple of years. Important to note, this is only for the Reynoldsburg location the Gahanna location is awesome. Went here because I accidentally ordered the pick up to the wrong location on DoorDash. Upon arrival, I was greeted by an employee who told me there was no order there for me. I sent my partner back in who had the email with confirmation the location listed. The employee said Oh yeah, a Dasher already picked up that order. to which he replied A Dasher came and picked up an order that was for customer pick up? The employee responded I don 't know what to say I can 't help you. and walked off from the counter. Like wh...

I really enjoy this restaurant. Their pizza is probably my favorite in Columbus. Unfortunately, when I called on May 11, 2022, at 8:35 PM, I was informed that they were no longer taking orders for the evening, even though they close at 9 PM. I understand that their hours are limited, but 25 minutes should be more than enough time to place an order. I could understand if it were only 10 minutes before closing, but this felt a bit excessive. When I mentioned to the staff member that I wanted to speak with a manager, she suddenly said they could take my order. At that point, it felt awkward, and I worried that my food might be compromised since I was planning to raise a concern. Although I don’... View menu