Johnny's Italian Steakhouse

8390 Market StreetWI 53562, Middleton, United States

🛍 Sushi, Pizza, Seafood, Italian

4.7 💬 380 Reviews
Johnny's Italian Steakhouse

Phone: +16088564040,+16088313705

Address: 8390 Market StreetWI 53562, Middleton, United States

City: Middleton

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 380

Website: http://www.johnnysitaliansteakhouse.com/

"I ordered the filet mignon, but it was an end cut full of tendons. I had it replaced with what seemed to be a sirloin cut, but I didn't end up eating the meal. The server was young and friendly, but didn't know how to open a bottle of wine. This was the worst dining experience I've had at this restaurant in many visits. I won't be returning."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Sandwiches

Salads

Soups

Specialty Beef & Chops

Blue Bar Burgers

Appetizers

Half Sandwich Selections

Starters

Combinations

Steaks & Filets

Baked Potatoes

Lunch Steaks

Seafood

Bread

Steaks

Steak Toppers

Pasta

Filled Paninis

Specialties

Traditional Pastas - Additions

Chicken

Comfort Food

Appetizers-Dinner

Traditional Pastas

Autograph Pastas

Entrées

Fish Dishes

Salads Add-On

Coleman Coleman

The food and atmosphere are excellent, as is the service

Address

Show Map

Reviews

River
River

We met old friends for dinner everything was fabulous!!!!


Alessia
Alessia

Service was great. Bone in ribeye was just okay. thought it would thicker than a sirloin


Camryn
Camryn

It was great. Ate outside. Quick service. Good food. Excellent server. Really wonderful dining experience View menu


Autumn
Autumn

Food was great. Cooked perfectly. We were seated in a booth in the main traffic lane, so ambiance was not so great


Josefa
Josefa

Meal was excellent. Even in the midst of the pandemic our steaks were excellent, and perfectly prepared. And as always, the service was outstanding


Luz
Luz

The food was delicious and we were impressed with the restaurant's adherence to social distancing guidelines and cleanliness. We had a great dining experience and look forward to returning soon. View menu


Cindy
Cindy

I have been here many times thru the years. Have the daily lunch special memorized. This visit I had the pick 2 for $14. The salad and Turkey, Bacon, Avocado was delicious! I might have to go back next week to enjoy it again.


Karlee
Karlee

The service was our least favorite part. Our waitress failed to communicate multiple things to us. She also seemed short with us when we had questions or was taking a while to order.Food was delicious!Little pricey.Overall a pretty good night out


Tia
Tia

I ordered the filet mignon, but it was an end cut full of tendons. I had it replaced with what seemed to be a sirloin cut, but I didn't end up eating the meal. The server was young and friendly, but didn't know how to open a bottle of wine. This was the worst dining experience I've had at this restaurant in many visits. I won't be returning. View menu

Categories

  • Sushi Delight in our exquisite sushi selection, featuring fresh ingredients, expertly crafted rolls, and traditional nigiri. Each bite offers a harmonious blend of flavors, promising a true taste of Japan.
  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time. View menu
  • Seafood Dive into the freshest catches of the sea with our seafood selection, featuring exquisite dishes prepared with high-quality fish and shellfish. Savor the flavors of the ocean in every bite!
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!

Amenities

  • Beer
  • Wine
  • menu
  • Banquet
  • menu
  • Delivery

Similar Restaurants

Midtown Pub

Midtown Pub

2405 Allen Blvd, Middleton, United States

Menu • Pub • Pubs • Grill • Burgers


"Okay, so my first visit 4 months ago the bar was dirty and I didn't like the food. That was my opinion. BUT, today (7/14) was on a different level. My daughters brought me back for lunch before we went bowling. Everything was great, food, service, everything. It was when we went to pay the bill that we had an issue. The prices on the menu did not match the bill. We asked to have it corrected and one waitress said she was sorry and would fix it right away. Then she came back with another waitress who informed us that there was a price increase and they had yet to change the prices on the menu. She apologized and informed us that is the way it is. I enquired about what was just and fair and even asked how they would view the situation if they were in our shoes. We got shoulder shrugs and the statement of IDK. So, I then asked what the laws were here in WI regarding prices and what rights we have as consumers to be protected against this sort of practice. We were then informed that they had already spoken to the manager and the decision was that the price is the price and they hoped that we were okay with it. Well, we are not okay with that practice. My daughter sorted it out like this, we basically had to pay a fee just to come eat there... I explained to my kids that it wasn't about the money as we would've given it in the tip. But the bottom line is, that up until today this operation has basically hijacked its customers . Today we showed them that for consumers that pay attention they now are hijacking their employees too. Tomorrow my daughters will get another lesson about the importance of the WI Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection. It is all about the principle..."