Phone: +18122652831
Address: 117 Ferry Street, Madison, Indiana, 47250, United States
City: Madison
Menu Dishes: 33
Reviews: 2691
Website: https://www.keywestshrimphouse.com/
"My waiter, Bryce, was exceptionally attentive and personable. He expertly explained the entrées and answered all my questions. I decided on the New York Strip, cooked medium, with lobster and a double-baked potato. Bryce assured me that "medium" really meant medium and, when my meal arrived, he asked me to check the steak to ensure it was to my liking. It was cooked to absolute perfection. The highlight of my evening occurred when the hostess returned to ask how I was enjoying my meal. Her evident passion for the restaurant piqued my interest, and I couldn't help but ask if she was the owner. To my surprise, she was! Hahahaha! Cathy took the time to share her story of how she became the owner, and what began as a brief conversation turned into a delightful 25-minute chat well after the restaurant had closed. I haven't felt this welcomed in a restaurant in a long time. With Cathy's South Carolina roots and southern charm, my experience was truly wonderful and unforgettable. I highly recommend Key West Shrimp House!"
Full menu - 33 options
All prices are estimates on menu.
Salads
Salad Bar
A salad bar offering a variety of fresh greens, toppings, and dressings to create your perfect personalized salad.
Entrées
Soup Du Jour
A fresh, daily handcrafted soup made with seasonal ingredients.
Shrimp Cocktail
Chilled shrimp served with tangy cocktail sauce for a classic appetizer.
Seafood Chowder
A rich and creamy soup brimming with fresh seafood, potatoes, and herbs.
For A Light Appetite
Daily Specials
Dinners
Baked Cod
Oven-baked cod fillet, tender and flaky, seasoned with herbs and lemon, served with a side of roasted vegetables.
Seafood
Crab Cakes
Deliciously golden brown crab cakes, packed with succulent crabmeat and seasonings.
Shrimp Scampi
Succulent shrimp sautéed in garlic butter sauce, served over linguine with a hint of lemon and fresh parsley.
Tradition Seafood
Sandwiches
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
Juicy grilled chicken breast served on a toasted bun with fresh lettuce and tomato.
Fish And Seafood Dishes
Catfish
Crispy fried catfish served with tangy tartar sauce and a side of zesty coleslaw.
Platters
Appetizers
Coconut Shrimp
Juicy shrimp coated in crispy coconut batter, fried until golden brown, served with tangy dipping sauce.
Pasta
Starters
Raw Bar
Peel Eat Shrimp
Boiled shrimp served chilled and ready to peel and enjoy, often accompanied by a tangy cocktail sauce.
Special Dinners
Fresh Fish & Seafood
French Fried Shrimp
Crispy and golden shrimp, deep-fried to perfection, served with tangy cocktail sauce.
Blue Plates
Bar Menu - Appetizers
Oysters Rockefeller
Fresh oysters topped with a rich mix of spinach, herbs, and breadcrumbs, baked to perfection.
Entree
Char-Grilled Oysters
Hoagies, Burgers &Amp; Hot Dogs
Justin
I visit Madison every year, but I've never had the chance to dine at the Key West Shrimp House, which has been around since before I was born. Believing that...
Address
Reviews
Kristie
This was a lovely, cozy spot to return to after exploring Clifty Falls and downtown Madison. With dawn approaching, the view over the river was absolutely breathtaking...
Jen
We stopped in for lunch today with our two kids before heading out of town after our annual Thanksgiving trip. We were pleasantly surprised by the safety measures in place...
Adele
Very relaxing atmosphere and location. The menu has many choices to satisfy your taste and inexpensive. Many parking spaces are available on a hardtop with handicap. We came to lunch and enjoyed the food and the waitress was excellent. View menu
Darrion
The food and the service were excellent, as always. My wife enjoyed the king crab legs, while I had lobster and grilled shrimp. We also ordered crab cakes and fried onions. Along with our meals and the salad bar, we were served seafood chowder and double-baked potatoes.
Tuur
Key West Shrimp House may not impress at first glance, but the interior tells a different story. The food is outstanding—pure comfort food made with fresh, wholesome ingredients that create a fantastic menu. The atmosphere reminds me of the quirky King Fish restaurants that once filled Louisville, but are now mostly gone. There's a charming "hole-in-the-wall" vibe to the place, but it’s definitely not a negative. The food is fantastic, the drinks are top-notch, and the history of the building, which used to be a button factory using bowls from Ohio River freshwater invertebrates, is fascinating. I had a wonderful time here!
Darius
My waiter, Bryce, was exceptionally attentive and personable. He expertly explained the entrées and answered all my questions. I decided on the New York Strip, cooked medium, with lobster and a double-baked potato. Bryce assured me that "medium" really meant medium and, when my meal arrived, he asked me to check the steak to ensure it was to my liking. It was cooked to absolute perfection. The highlight of my evening occurred when the hostess returned to ask how I was enjoying my meal. Her evident passion for the restaurant piqued my interest, and I couldn't help but ask if she was the owner. To my surprise, she was! Hahahaha! Cathy took the time to share her story of how she became the own... View menu
Madison
Madison is known for its vibrant food scene, including cheese curds, bratwurst, and farm-to-table dishes.
Categories
-
Soup Warm and comforting soups to nourish your soul. Choose from a variety of flavorful broths and hearty ingredients, perfect for a simple appetizer or a satisfying meal on a chilly day.
-
Pasta Delight in our selection of classic and contemporary pasta dishes, each crafted with fresh, quality ingredients and flavorful sauces that capture the essence of Italian cuisine in every bite. View menu
-
Seafood Dive into the freshest catches of the sea with our seafood selection, featuring exquisite dishes prepared with high-quality fish and shellfish. Savor the flavors of the ocean in every bite!
-
American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.
Amenities
-
Takeout
-
Reservations
- menu
-
Families With Children
- menu
