Trattoria Stefano - Menu

Terrific service provided by Michael and others. My delicious halibut dish didn’t quite “work” as the sauce and other accoutrements would be better adorning a different protein. I’m of the opinion fine fresh fish shouldn’t be smothered so much.

Sat at the bar for a few drinks. Wasn’t greeted pleasantly whatsoever. Finished my drink (it was amazing) and went 10 minutes without being asked for another. The bar or restaurant wasn’t even busy. Settled my tab and got asked for more money on the tip by the new bartender. Can’t even make that up.

Mushroom risotto was good, salad was good, chicken dish was very salty. It was so salty that I couldn’t eat it. The restaurant comped my meal which was nice, but I was very disappointed about my main course as I heard such great things about the restaurant. The flourless chocolate cake was delicious. View menu

Very good Italian. Cool location in Downtown Sheboygan. So five stars would be on par with best Italian I ever had, 4 stars. This was up there. Authentic, great food with one small issue. My chair wasn’t comfortable. A great restaurant like this and you’re going to be there a while. When we were done my bottom was ready to go.

I'm a bit conflicted about this restaurant... Almost 5 stars, but not quite. The limited menu was a downside for me. The service and appetizers were excellent, and the halibut I ordered was very good. However, the tomato soup was just okay. Overall, it was a good meal and I would consider coming back. The location is also really nice.

The food at T.S. is absolutely delicious from start to finish. Every course, from the aperitif to the digestive, is well executed. The attention to detail is impressive, creating an authentic experience. The cocktails alone are worth a visit, but a meal here will leave you feeling extremely satisfied. After visiting 7 years ago, this was our second visit and we will continue to return every time we are in Sheboygan! View menu

This restaurant took me back to Rome! Brandon suggested the chef's special, which was fantastic - a chicken ragù with fresh pasta. Whenever I see fresh sepia or cuttlefish on the menu, I always order it, and this dish did not disappoint. I'm glad I had the bread (you must try the bread) because I couldn't get enough of the sauce with every bite! The tiramisu was decadent. And don't forget to order the cappuccino - it's a must!

The food was absolutely incredible. I'm upset I paid 153$ and our server forgot our old fashioned , after waiting so long we stopped another server to grab us something else. Didn't bring any bread to our table till after I asked well after our appetizer came out. I had one small glass of water and he didn't ever come to refill it again or my boyfriends. Ordered a tiramsu at the end and he forgot to bring us it and we had to go ask someone to get us one to go because we were just ready to leave at that point . He barely came to the table , we wanted more stuff but he was just never around . For 153 I kind of expect better service then that. That was my first time here and it makes me not wan...

My review of Trattoria Stefano: Often, when you return to a place cloaked in fond memories of nostalgia, it lets you down. It's like seeing an old flame thirty years later, and you question the original infatuation. Well, Stefano's stirred my passions as if 15 years meant not a thing. After strolling Sheboygan's beautiful revitalized waterfront, we drove to Stefano's, parking in their rear lot. The restaurant looked the same, and we found two empty seats at the large front room bar. Ashley, behind the bar, was gracious and helpful, and we ordered wine from Stefano's eclectic offerings. While not as groundbreaking as 20 years ago, the wine list is still interesting and has reasonable pricing.... View menu