Phone: +16316662899
Address: 28 Cottage Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States
City: Bay Shore
Menu Dishes: 35
Reviews: 2666
Website: http://www.fatfish.info/
"It's fantastic that you can finally make reservations at this restaurant. I never understood why a restaurant would want to be “surprised” by customer demand. Fortunately, they are now well-staffed with a great team working together to ensure everything runs smoothly. The food is quite good. Our ceviche appetizer was outstanding—enough for two but definitely suitable for four as a sharing dish. My wife ordered the halibut special for her main course, which was very good and nicely accompanied by a corn salad, roasted baby potatoes, and asparagus. I opted for several tapas dishes. The lamb chops were consistently delicious. I also tried the tuna tacos and empanadas; the tuna was excellent. However, the empanadas were just okay—the dipping sauce was overly spicy, and they didn't have that homemade texture and flavor. They might be great for curing a hangover, though! I will definitely be returning. The views are unbeatable, and the service is top-notch."
Full menu - 35 options
All prices are estimates on menu.
Salads
Greek Salad
Fresh and vibrant salad with tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, feta cheese, and a drizzle of olive oil.
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce tossed with creamy Caesar dressing, Parmesan cheese, and crunchy croutons.
Appetizer
Shrimp Tacos
Delicious shrimp tacos with fresh vegetables, tangy sauce, and soft tortillas, offering a burst of flavors in every bite.
Steamed Mussels
Fresh steamed mussels in white wine broth, served with garlic and herbs.
Seafood
Calamari
Tender calamari rings lightly breaded and fried to golden perfection, served with tangy marinara sauce for a delightful appetizer.
Grilled Octopus
Tender grilled octopus served with a zesty lemon dressing and a sprinkle of fresh herbs.
Octopus And Orzo
Tender octopus served with flavorful orzo, combining Mediterranean ingredients for a delightful seafood dish.
Entrées
Crab Cake menu
Savory crab cakes with a crispy exterior, packed with flavorful crab meat and herbs, served with a zesty sauce.
Clams Oreganata
Baked clams topped with garlic, breadcrumbs, and oregano, served golden and flavorful.
Starters
Pasta
Fettuccine
Fettuccine served in a creamy Alfredo sauce with rich Parmesan and a hint of garlic, topped with fresh herbs.
Soups
Lobster Bisque
Rich and creamy lobster bisque, infused with sherry, offering a luxurious blend of smooth texture and savory seafood flavors.
Mains
Dessert
Crepes
Thin pancakes filled with sweet or savory fillings, perfect for any meal of the day.
Rice
Risotto
Creamy Arborio rice cooked to perfection, with a rich blend of Parmesan and fresh seasonal vegetables.
Gnocchi
Gnocchi
Soft potato dumplings served with a creamy pesto sauce and topped with Parmesan cheese.
Mexican-American Food
Empanadas
Savory pastries filled with spiced meat or vegetables, wrapped in a crisp, golden crust.
Fish Dishes
Fish & Chips
Crispy golden fried fish fillet served with classic French fries, a side of tangy tartar sauce, and a lemon wedge.
Special Rolls
Lobster Roll
Succulent lobster meat blended with a touch of mayo and spices, served in a soft, buttery roll for a taste of coastal delight.
Nibbles & Sharing Boards
Chicken
Grilled Chicken
Juicy grilled chicken seasoned to perfection, served hot and tender.
Fajitas
Three Choice Menu Iii
Burger
Pizza
Prawns / Shrimps
Hibachi Entrees
Robert
Fantastic food and service. The location is a bonus! be back soon, with the boat. ;
Address
Reviews
Kayley
Beautiful location, good band with excellent food and service. Will go back and recommend.
Julia
Went for lunch with my mom. Had great wine (recommended by our waitress), great view, relaxed atmosphere. We loved it!
Robert
Food was perfect, hot, delicious and each course was nicely spaced. Wait service was excellent. View was beautiful, sunny clear with big waves. Live music added to the mood. View menu
Sage
This restaurant is excellent, with a fantastic and unique menu that offers fresh and abundant options. My family and I have made this our go-to spot. The service is outstanding, and while the cocktails aren't cheap, they are absolutely worth every dollar.
Kailee
The food is incredible, the staff is friendly and attentive, and the views are breathtaking, all within a casually elegant setting. Whether it's for a special occasion or simply to enjoy a laid-back summer evening by the Great South Bay, Fat Fish is always a fantastic option.
CherylR
The setting is fantastic but the prices for the lackluster food are disproportionately high. I have returned because the convenient location and the setting of being on over the water but continue to find the food not great while being priced as if it is fine dining which it is not. View menu
Raoul
The atmosphere of being on the water is fun!! The food was great and the service even better! My daughter didn't like her dinner so they immediately substituted it out at no extra charge. We had the oyster shooters, saffron mussels, lamb chops, steak. shrimp/scallop fettuccine ... it was delicious!! Can't wait to go back!!!
Charity
I visited on the opening night of the 2017 season. Despite the awful weather, the food was outstanding. I particularly loved the steak skewers and the halibut. I also sampled a few other dishes, including chicken with avocado and cilantro purée, rice and artichoke "kissen," small peppers stuffed with shrimp risotto, and crab cakes. Every dish was exceptional. The bartenders were attentive and friendly as well. I can’t wait to return when the weather is warmer!
LouG
It's fantastic that you can finally make reservations at this restaurant. I never understood why a restaurant would want to be “surprised” by customer demand. Fortunately, they are now well-staffed with a great team working together to ensure everything runs smoothly. The food is quite good. Our ceviche appetizer was outstanding—enough for two but definitely suitable for four as a sharing dish. My wife ordered the halibut special for her main course, which was very good and nicely accompanied by a corn salad, roasted baby potatoes, and asparagus. I opted for several tapas dishes. The lamb chops were consistently delicious. I also tried the tuna tacos and empanadas; the tuna was excellent. Ho... View menu
Bay Shore
Bay Shore is a charming coastal town known for seafood dining, with local favorites like clam chowder, fresh oysters, and lobster rolls being typical culinary delights.
Categories
-
Fish Delight in our exquisite fish dishes, crafted from the freshest catch of the day. From grilled favorites to savory stews, our menu celebrates the ocean's bounty with flavors to satisfy every palate.
-
Tapas Enjoy a delightful variety of small, flavorful dishes perfect for sharing, combining traditional and modern influences. Savor each bite as you explore diverse tastes and textures crafted to excite your palate. View menu
-
Seafood Dive into the freshest catches of the sea with our seafood selection, featuring exquisite dishes prepared with high-quality fish and shellfish. Savor the flavors of the ocean in every bite!
-
Terrace Dine al fresco on our beautiful terrace, where you can enjoy a delightful meal amidst stunning views and a refreshing breeze. Perfect for a relaxing lunch or a romantic dinner under the stars.
Amenities
-
Delivery
-
Reservations
- menu
-
Outdoor Seating
- menu
