Nickel’s Pit Bbq - Menu

A great little BBQ joint. The staff was very friendly and informative. The food would make any Texan proud as it had great flavor and portions.

Have called there 4 times in a week between the hours of 5 and 6:30 pm and wanted there number 1 appetizer pig wings and have been sold out!! Do they only make 10 of them a day ? Won't be trying to order anymore... place is a joke

Holy shit. Best BBQ I've had in my life. I got brisket, smoked turkey and pig wings with an everything dry rub. Fair warning; try your pig wings before you dip them in the included ranch, they're PERFECT as is. Anyone dipping them should be arrested for a food based hate crime. Bravo Nickels p.s. we also ate at Nichols and Watkins Glen a few years ago..also amazing. Food: 5 View menu

Regarding the sauces, the Carolina sauce was sweet and very mild, lacking much depth. The house BBQ sauce had a rich flavor, but I felt it was missing something. There was another BBQ sauce—which I can't recall the name of— that had a nice vinegary base and was quite enjoyable. We also ordered the onion rings and three tacos. The taco special at $3 per taco is a great deal compared to other items on the menu. My personal favorite was the pickle barrel, and the onion rings were outstanding. I loved the beer batter, though I wished they were a bit less greasy. Overall, I would definitely come back to try more items from the menu.

For wings, there are plenty of options to choose from. I tried the dry rub BBQ (10) and the chipotle honey mustard (10), and both were delicious. I appreciated their crispy texture. The brisket was served as nice, thick slices that had a good amount of smoky flavor. However, I felt it could have benefited from a bit more smoking time to make it more tender. As for the ribs (not pictured), they seemed either steamed or boiled. While they did fall off the bone easily, I prefer my ribs to have a smoky flavor and a bit of resistance when I bite into them. Additionally, I like having the barbecue sauce infused onto the meat rather than served separately. These ribs came without sauce, and you...

We were hungry and bbq sounded good. Well it was Taco Wednesday at a bbq joint. My wife and I each ordered 3. I had fries and we shared a fried pickles appetizer. Oh don't forget the margaritas. The pickles were the best fried pickles I've ever had. And they were a first for my wife. She loved them. House pickled and cut thick, then deep fried to perfection. Taco's were great we didn't have one we didn't like, but the loaded brisket taco was the best. Great margaritas not too sweet, and enough tequila to get a nice flavor. Paul was our server and was the perfect blend of attentiveness, professionalism,and friendliness, without hovering. Definitely added to our experience. We left stuffed and... View menu

I came upon this bbq restaurant after leaving another bbq joint in the area, that was not so good. This is a small restaurant so it gets crowded pretty quickly. I was greeted and seated immediately with a great attitude and smile from the hostess. The very hospitable waiter helped me to choose my meal. The hot and ready to eat food probably took about only 10 minutes or so to come out. First thing I wanted to taste, was the french fries to make sure they were fried crisp and not soaked in oil, they were light crisp and fresh. The ribs were very tender, although I could not taste the seasoning too well, but who needs the added salt anyway, right?! The wings were prepared just right, they disp...

Came here for a late lunch/early dinner after driving a few hours from Long Island so we were all very hungry! We must have walked in at the perfect time because our wait was only 15 minutes, meanwhile everyone else who came in after had at least a 40 minute wait. We did a quick walk around the quaint town while we waited. Once we sit down, the waitress came over quickly and we ordered. I got the quarter chicken, fries and mac salad as well as the 2 little corn muffins that come on the side. We also ordered a side of onion rings for the table and I was so glad we did because they were some of the best onion rings I have ever had!!! They were large and crispy and had a little hint of salt tha...

No Complaints! Excellent Service! We showed up News Year Eve around 3pm. The place was busy but there was availability for 4. Score! No wait. Emma and Ryan provided excellent hospitality. We really like that their POS system is mobile. I had been searching for a good place in the Finger Lakes that serves Central Texas style sliced brisket and Nichol's get 5 Stars for providing! While eating I danced in my chair a little bit and made a lot of happy sounding eating grunts and moans. I had positive flashbacks of my times eating at Hard Eight BBQ in Stephenville, TX. Thank you Nichol's for helping me relive those BBQ eating memories. We ordered 10 smoked wings (big tasty wings and legs from matu... View menu