Shortstop Deli - Menu

A customer and an employee got into a conflict. As I was leaving the building, the customer confronted me and even yelled at my toddler. The portions of the food were not particularly generous, and the cucumbers I received were spoiled.

Seems to be a must-visit if you?re in town, so stopped by for a bagel. The sandwiches looked fantastic and according to all the other reviews are a must try. The bagel was great and the cream cheese delicious. No place to sit inside so be ready to take out. Service was fast and friendly.

It’s definitely a must-visit when you’re in town, so I stopped by for a bagel. The sandwiches looked amazing, and based on all the other reviews, I had to try one. The bagel was excellent, and the cream cheese was delicious. There isn’t a place to sit inside, so it’s more of a grab-and-go spot. The service was quick and friendly. View menu

If you're in town, this place is definitely one you shouldn't miss, so I dropped in for a bagel. The sandwiches looked amazing and, based on all the other reviews, they're a must-try. The bagel I had was excellent, and the cream cheese was delightful. There isn't any seating inside, so be prepared for takeout. The service was quick and friendly, too.

Excellent made to order subs, sandwiches, breakfast and more! Love to get a hot open-faced English muffin egg and cheese on after a long night of work. Or a sub to get me through a long day. The coffee is bold and deliciouss; Always fresh and hot. I was introduced to ssd back in college. One of my teammates was local(still is) and got us hooked so every time we came to Ithaca we got SSD. Now I try to make it a regular stop.

Best subs and cheesesteaks in Ithaca by a country mile. Really good bread quality and sandwich ingredients, and huge portions. Beautiful neon signs, hacky convenience store-items, and the ceiling dripping into a bucket set the ambiance to your gastronomic romp. It really doesn't even get close so there's no second place, but I guess that stand in Wegmans can get an honorable third mention. Definitely don't get the tater tots tho, but why would you at a sub store? View menu

We were visiting from Cleveland for the holiday weekend. After a Hike by the Ithaca Falls, we discovered this great looking deli shop. It was beyond amazing and delicious! Everything is made fresh in front of you. Their sandwiches are huge, filling and stuffed with toppings. You definitely get your money?s worth. Their chili is also phenomenal. I highly recommend this deli stop to anyone local and visiting. The staff is the nicest group of people. Very friendly, polite and helpful. Thank you for a great experience :

My point is that in the restaurant business, time management is crucial. Just imagine how much busier it gets! I’ve worked in restaurants since I was 12, managing tables and dishes, and I’ve been a sous chef for over 10 years in fine dining. The decline in cooking skills due to the reliance on machines is part of why I chose to start my own business working with animals. Customers need to feel heard, and it's surprising how often that doesn't happen anymore. On a positive note, the sub itself was good, and I would consider returning, but I wanted to share my experience so it can be handled better next time. Don't worry too much about being the best sub shop in Ithaca; focus on listening to...

This would have been a easy 5 star rating if the customer service was better. I went to place my order and the young lady with tattoos on wrist is the one who took my order. I explained to her I wanted my sub ran through the belt oven twice. She began to talk over me and Tell me I get it you want it toasted extra crispy . Well I was the only person in line important to know , my sub came out and I requested again please run it twice , she said if she ran it twice it burn so she folded the sub and stuck it in for the third time while baby sitting it ........ see where I'm going with this ? That belt oven bakes food while be ran through the oven . My point is prioritize your time in the restau... View menu