The Shed - Menu

Oh my goodness delicious!!! The **** Mary is a perfect start to brunch! Hands down the best pancakes I?ve ever had?even better than mine! So light and fluffy? like heaven!! So yummy I took some to go for my kids at home. ?????

Decided at last minute to go to dinner on a Tuesday evening. We were able to get seated at a quaint table for 2 by the front window. The service was great with all staff welcoming and friendly. Lots of great choices for food which came out hot and delicious.

Absolutely wonderful! Sydney was a magnificent, attentive and charismatic waitress! The food was filling, healthy options, and unique as well as delicious. The drinks were amazing! I loved the farmers gin it was super refreshing! Definitely a place I would visit again! View menu

I strongly recommend this restaurant! The ambiance is charming, the service is prompt and friendly, and the food is tasty—I loved everything I tried. I intend to come back next time I'm in Sayville. My experience at The Shed was wonderful. This is their second location on Long Island, and it's truly impressive! I also enjoyed The Shed Restaurant in Huntington, so I recommend both locations.

The bill came to $112 after tax and tip, which felt reasonable for the quality of the food. We did have one minor issue: one of our guests didn't care for the watermelon juice, as it tasted overripe. However, the waitress quickly replaced it with pineapple juice and even removed the charge for the questionable drink from our bill. The only other small detail was that there were several napkins with lipstick stains, but that's understandable given how challenging it can be to get those out. Overall, it was a great dining experience!

Had dinner here a few days ago. There's plenty of parking in the back. We came in through the door by the parking lot. The bar is really nice. We went to the hostess and were seated right away at a cute booth for 2. Pur waitress came over right away. We had drinks that were really nice and ordered an appetizer. The mac and cheese. It was so yummy!!! For dinner we had a salad and the lobster roll. Again, super yummy. The Shed will definitely become a place we go to often. Looking forward to the next time we go back. Good food and good service!! View menu

The parking lot was crowded, and I think we snagged the last available spot. Once we entered, we were quickly seated at the best table in the restaurant. The staff was very attentive, checking in on us just the right amount—neither too pushy nor too distant. The menu is consistently excellent. We enjoyed deviled eggs, calamari, and shared a Cobb salad, along with Short Rib sandwiches accompanied by roasted mushrooms. Everything was delicious, though the deviled eggs were just okay, but that’s a matter of personal taste. For dessert, we had a Belgian waffle topped with three scoops of ice cream. I was completely satisfied. I'd happily do this all over again and again!

This restaurant is quite popular, and for good reason! Make sure to arrive early so the wait is bearable. There's a lovely bar inside where you can enjoy a drink while waiting for your table, or you can relax outside on a nice day. Dogs are welcome in the outdoor seating area. The interior is stunning, bright, and filled with natural light. The drinks are fantastic—try The Pink Panther and The Shed Lemonade. Both the Fried Chicken Sandwich and the Smoke Burger are delicious. The burger is cooked to a perfect medium, while the chicken is crispy and juicy. Don't miss the Gouda Fries, and the sweet potato fries are perfectly crispy and well-seasoned. I can't wait to visit again!

Wow! Usually, we stick to local spots in Smithtown since there are plenty of restaurants here, but I discovered The Shed through Bring Fido, an app that helps dog owners find pet-friendly places. We brought our puppy and sat outside. But let's get to the important part—the food was outstanding! The calamari was the best I’ve ever had (no exaggeration!) with fried peppers and an amazing basil sauce. The chicken sandwich and summer salad were both incredible too. We also tried the chocolate cake for dessert, and it was delicious! I really hope they open a location in Smithtown someday, but for now, I don’t mind making the trip to West Sayville. Everything was fantastic! I wanted to take photos... View menu