Tony's Cafe - Menu

366 Possum Park Rd, Newark, United States Of America, 19711

🛍 Cafe, Pizza, Coffee, Cheese

4.5 💬 1879 Reviews

Phone: +13027372411

Address: 366 Possum Park Rd, Newark, United States Of America, 19711

City: Newark

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 1879

Website: http://www.ilovetonyscafe.com/

"I am absolutely blown away by the incredible pizza at this restaurant. It is hands down the best pizza I have ever tasted. My family and I love trying pizza from different places when we travel, and this place definitely takes the cake. The sauce is amazing and you can see them cutting fresh tomatoes right in front of you. The ingredients are all fresh and they have a wide variety to choose from. The prices are very reasonable for the size of the pizzas. The service was also exceptional, with incredibly friendly staff who were attentive to our needs. I am in awe of how fantastic this place is."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Pizza

Salads

Entrées

Chicken Wings

Italian Sandwiches

Extreme Pizzas

Main Course

Stone Oven Pizza

Chicken

Chicken Dishes

Low Carb Wraps

Specialty Pizzas

Specilty Pizza

Steak And Skewer

Vegetarian Dishes

Bakery

Seafood Dishes

Grinders

Starters

Amos Amos

The people are great and the food is even better. Go visit Dhara and you won’t be disappointed Kid-friendliness: great munchies and portions

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Nicole
Nicole

I used Tony’s cafe for delivery for a catering order. The food was fantastic! Amazing Alfredo pastas, bruschetta, cannoli. The office raved about all of it and reasonably priced.


Scott
Scott

Love this place and its people. The food is good, great for the price and fast. The people are awesome! The only reason not 5 stars is because it's always packed and hard to find a seat.


Amy
Amy

I'm a transplanted New Yorker and this is the best pizza outside of NY. We're moved 35 mins north to PA and will happily drive there for dinner. If I'm shopping in DE, I plan my driving around stopping in. The staff is friendly as well. View menu


Meghann
Meghann

This place is amazing! We ordered meatballs, ziti, and pasta salad for a birthday party and every single person who attended said “the food is so good! Where did you get it?” It was so easy to order from them, they were so accommodating and friendly. We will 100% continue to eat at their restaurant and order from them for catering events


Biljana
Biljana

My husband and I visited Tony's Cafe Pizza for the first time today, after traveling from Washington DC. We were extremely pleased with the food, service, and atmosphere. We would like to express our gratitude to Dara Shah, Danny, and the other staff members at this fantastic Italian pizza place. And a special thanks for the delicious cannoli! - B&J Regan


Aimee
Aimee

Our school just had a very large catering order for Teacher Appreciation week. It was a huge hit! We put in the order last minute and they were able to have the very large order ready for us. We needed it at 11am and they had it fully ready to go. The food was excellent and the teachers really appreciated such a great lunch on a Monday afternoon! We’ll be catering from them in the future for other events at our school! View menu


Ann
Ann

The restaurant is more of a pick up and go style with as another reviewer said “truly snug seating” if you dine in. The staff were very nice! We had half Chicken Cacciatore Pizza and half Crab pizza, which is unusual but perfect for us. The pizza was Not the best NY style pizza we’ve had. The chicken on the pizza tasted old. The crab was good with Old Bay seasoning on top of course. Not a place I would purposely visit again for the food.


Ray
Ray

Overall, this restaurant has everything I look for in a pizza place. It is fast, friendly, serves delicious food, and has a great atmosphere. I ordered meatballs, mozzarella sticks, and a slice of pepperoni pizza. The meatballs were tasty, the mozzarella sticks were good, and the pizza was excellent. I just wish the sauce for the pizza and meatballs had a bit more flavor, but they were still good. They also gave me a side of bread which was fantastic. I will definitely be making Tony's Cafe my regular go-to spot for pizza.


Natallie
Natallie

I am absolutely blown away by the incredible pizza at this restaurant. It is hands down the best pizza I have ever tasted. My family and I love trying pizza from different places when we travel, and this place definitely takes the cake. The sauce is amazing and you can see them cutting fresh tomatoes right in front of you. The ingredients are all fresh and they have a wide variety to choose from. The prices are very reasonable for the size of the pizzas. The service was also exceptional, with incredibly friendly staff who were attentive to our needs. I am in awe of how fantastic this place is. View menu

Newark

Newark

Newark, a spirited city in New Jersey, is known for its rich cultural diversity, often reflected in its food scene, which features Portuguese and Brazilian dishes, like rodizio and pastel de nata.

Categories

  • Cafe Indulge in our vibrant cafe selection, offering an array of freshly brewed coffees, artisanal teas, and delectable pastries, paired with cozy ambiance for a delightful dining experience.
  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time. View menu
  • Coffee Indulge in our rich and aromatic coffee selection, expertly brewed to awaken your senses. From classic espresso to creamy lattes, discover the perfect blend to start your day on a flavorful note.
  • Cheese A curated selection of artisanal cheeses from around the world, featuring diverse flavors and textures that delight the palate. Perfect for sharing or savored individually with the ideal accompaniments.

Amenities

  • Takeout
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Mastercard
  • menu
  • Local Cuisine

Similar Restaurants

Banzai Sushi Hibachi

Banzai Sushi Hibachi

671 Market Street, Newark, 07105, United States Of America

Menu • Tea • Soup • Sushi • Asiatic


"On Wednesday 12/06 I went to Banzai Sushi, I have never received such bad service in my life… Every time I remember my experience, I get angry, the waitress is rude and has a horrible attitude! It's a shame because the food there is wonderful, but the service is so SO BAD that I lost my appetite. When I got there, there was some water spilled on the table, she took my stepfather's DIRTY NAPKIN to clean it and just left it there. When I asked for things she responded with an ignorant, rude tone. My partner doesn't eat any type of animal protein other than shrimp. So we asked if we could replace the salmon with shrimp in a poke, she checked in the kitchen and said everything was fine. When she came back, I placed my order and she was doing something at the other table, but said to continue because she was listening….my partner also talking about swapping salmon for shrimp at the end and the waitress replies “so it's not like that at all what you want, is something different” and simply left leaving us talking to the wall. When our order arrived, my order came out wrong. I called her and she simply replied “BUT ALSO, WITH HER MAKING ALL THIS MESS WITH SALMON AND SHRIMP…”, sorry, but for me that was the end of the bite. It's okay to get the order wrong, I know it happens, but blaming the customer? Every time she passed by our table I saw her making faces and looking at the kitchen. I thought it was a huge lack of respect, we are paying customers. On top of that, it also includes a 15% tip. Normally, if I receive good service, I will give 20%, after all, I work in customer service and value professionals in my field. And if the service was just bad, I wouldn't bother coming here to report it... But it was horrible"