Johnny Utah's - Menu

25 West 51st StreetNY 10016, New York, United States

🛍 Pub, Drinks, Chicken, Western

3.2 💬 4025 Reviews
Johnny Utah's

Phone: +12122658824

Address: 25 West 51st StreetNY 10016, New York, United States

City: New York

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 4025

"First of all, I don't agree with the description of energetic for the noise level. It was more annoyingly loud than energetic. I was expecting something similar to Texas Roadhouse but, felt more like we were at a Hooter's! This was one of the few places we were able to reserve a table at while we were in NYC. We showed up a little early, there were open tables everywhere so we did get in earlier than reserved. However, when we made it down stairs and inside I thought we'd walked through the back door. The hostess was sitting down with someone else and eating her own plate of food. Took her a while to even greet us. Once she raced us to our table we had to wait seven minutes for a server to acknowledge us. There was only one other full table in her area. She wasn't friendly either and still don't know her name. The restaurant doesn't offer a gluten free menu so I had to take a chance and hope I didn't get sick. We ordered the fajitas to share thinking the meat should be prepared safely. When it arrived my first thought was it was the frozen, ready to heat sliced fajita meats. They added so much paprika and seasoning the peppers and onions couldn't be tasted. My side of broccoli came later after I reminded them there was one. The kitchen staff who served that was much friendlier than our waitress. This was just an unfriendly experience and not an establishment I'd recommend while in NYC."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Burger

Entrées

Starters

Chicken

Platters

Seafood

Pork

Bread Selection

Brunch Sides

Between The Bun

Vegetarian

Wines & Bubbles

Sparkling Wine / Champagne

Soup, Salad, And Chili

Dips, Snacks, & Small Plates

Pork Dishes*

Chicken Dishes

Soups

Tavern Bites

Eggs

Shareables

Main Courses

Delicious Main Courses

Sandwiches

Shareable Sides

Soups & Greens

Boot Cocktails

User User

Manager was the best! Did everything they could to accommodate us!

Address

Show Map

Reviews

OpenTable
OpenTable

Our server Jessica was fantastic, the food was delicious, and the drinks were incredible!


Adam
Adam

Service was horrific. The server clearly did not care. Food was over 2 hours to receive. Would advise all to stay away.


michelleKaplan
michelleKaplan

Food was bland, not appetizing. Even the diet coke had a weird taste, must have been RC Much to noisy. You could not hear yourself talk. View menu


AliBee
AliBee

More of a bar than a restaurant. Lots of drink choices. Food was good ribs tender but very fatty. Sliders and sides good. Mechanical bull was fun.


ScottFan
ScottFan

Johnny Utah's has great hearty servings of food, the atmosphere is energetic and fun! They should however add servers...our server was so busy, we were left a few times sitting at the table trying to get her attention...


GiaD
GiaD

We waited for 18 minutes before a server finally came to our table, even though the restaurant was not busy. The $38 steak I ordered medium-rare came out half well done and half medium. The rest of the food was below average considering the price. Although we enjoyed the trivia game and the host, we do not plan on returning. View menu


RebeccaF
RebeccaF

I went with a group of friends to celebrate a birthday and we had a blast. There were 8 of us so they gave us our own room. Service was very good, great selection of food and a really fun vibe. Riding the bull was so much fun and the people were really friendly. Also ordered the sangria in the cowboy boot. Overall, a great experience!! Would highly recommend and plan on going back.


BogiM
BogiM

We arrived at the restaurant after 4 pm and requested a table, only to be told that they only accept reservations and not walk-in guests. After checking their website, we found a available table at 5 pm and booked it. However, when we returned at 5 pm, the hostess (who was rude and unhelpful) informed us that we would not be seated because the reservation was made shortly before. A kinder lady then informed us that the kitchen was busy and we would have to wait 20-30 minutes, to which we agreed. The rude hostess returned and shouted at us, insisting that the reservation was made just 5 minutes ago and we would not be seated. Despite showing them our reservation through their website, they di...


AmberK
AmberK

First of all, I don't agree with the description of energetic for the noise level. It was more annoyingly loud than energetic. I was expecting something similar to Texas Roadhouse but, felt more like we were at a Hooter's! This was one of the few places we were able to reserve a table at while we were in NYC. We showed up a little early, there were open tables everywhere so we did get in earlier than reserved. However, when we made it down stairs and inside I thought we'd walked through the back door. The hostess was sitting down with someone else and eating her own plate of food. Took her a while to even greet us. Once she raced us to our table we had to wait seven minutes for a server to a... View menu

Categories

  • Pub Enjoy a lively atmosphere with our classic pub favorites. From hearty burgers and fish 'n' chips to savory pies and craft brews, our menu promises a cozy experience ideal for unwinding with friends.
  • Drinks Quench your thirst with our refreshing selection of drinks, from hand-crafted cocktails and fine wines to non-alcoholic delights, including sodas, juices, and expertly brewed coffee and tea. Perfect complements to your meal! View menu
  • Chicken Succulent and savory, our chicken dishes are crafted with tender meat, flavorful seasonings, and diverse culinary inspirations. Enjoy a delectable variety that's sure to satisfy every palate.
  • Western Savor the flavors of the West with our diverse menu featuring classic favorites like juicy burgers, succulent steaks, and creamy pastas. Each dish is crafted with premium ingredients for an unforgettable dining experience.

Amenities

  • Amex
  • Dancing
  • menu
  • Discover
  • menu
  • Visa Card

Similar Restaurants

Bread N Wine

Bread N Wine

1417 Lexington Ave, New York City I-10128-1613, United States

Menu • Wine • French • Coffee • American


"We went to Bread N Wine on a early Saturday afternoon for brunch. We were greeted and seated by the servers who were attentive. The food was okay the bread was really soft and fresh. My partner got the French Lentil Soup, Spinach and Tomato Egg Bake andI got the French onion soup, egg omelette with spicy tomato avocado and onions. I wasn 't happy with my omelette because thespicy just meant it was covered in hot sauce within. For beverages, we got chai lattes (we later found out it wasn 't tea basedbut rather coffee) and we had the option of oat milk, almond milk or regular milk. In terms of our overall experience we feltby the end too many things were steering the experience south; the worst was when we were accused of using counterfeit money topay for the tip. There was no special marker used to prove that the money was counterfeit or technology to back up this claim.That experience alone left a bad taste in our mouth as we left embarrassed by that claim, kind of shook from that, we stilladded the tip to our credit card 18%. As we walked out and talked about how weird that was, the owner of the business nextdoor overheard us and asked to see the $20 bill he showed us that our money was real and validated what we knew, that themoney wasn 't counterfeit. When we went back into Bread N Wine to discuss this there was no apology, just well, it felt thatway , shrug. It left a terrible feeling. We would not go back after that, this is not how you treat customers from start tofinish, hence the 2 star review."