Phone: +16464846200
Address: 421 Amsterdam Ave, New York City I-10024-5813, United States
City: New York City
Menu Dishes: 35
Reviews: 6845
Website: https://www.madeinnewyorkpizza.com/
"I’ve been coming here for years whenever I am on the Upper West Side or wanting to have pizza in the park. It was one of my favorite pizza places in the city. There are several different pizza places with the same name and signage as this one on 80th and Amsterdam but I believe this is the best. It is a very standard pizza place with usually plenty of seating. I’d say it can be very hot inside the restaurant on a hot day. Always look for the pies that look like they have been made recently as they typically taste the best. I can’t recommend this place more and can’t wait to go back."
Full menu - 35 options
All prices are estimates on menu.
Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese pizza featuring a rich tomato sauce, gooey mozzarella, and fresh basil on a crisp, golden crust.
Pizza Margherita
Classic Pizza Margherita with fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, fresh basil, olive oil, and a light crispy crust.
Specialty Pies
Sides
Garlic Knots
Soft, warm dough knots infused with garlic and herbs, served with marinara dipping sauce.
Dessert
Tiramisu
A classic Italian dessert featuring layers of coffee-soaked ladyfingers, rich mascarpone cream, and a dusting of cocoa powder.
Cannolis
Crispy pastry shells filled with creamy ricotta, chocolate chips, and a hint of citrus zest, dusted with powdered sugar.
Ny Cheesecake
Creamy and rich cheesecake with a crumbly graham cracker crust, offering a classic New York flavor with a smooth finish.
Pizza Pies
Salads
House Salad
Classic garden salad with mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, and carrots with your choice of dressing.
Cesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce, creamy Caesar dressing, croutons, and Parmesan cheese.
Chicken
Chicken Roll
A delicious roll filled with flavorful chicken, herbs, and spices, wrapped in a soft bread or pastry.
Buffalo Chicken
Spicy fried chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, served with celery sticks and blue cheese dressing.
Bottled Beer
Mixed Dishes
Cheese Pie
A savory pie filled with a blend of creamy, melted cheeses encased in a flaky, golden crust.
Import, Craft Beer & Cider
Desserts
Chocolate Cake
Rich and moist chocolate cake layered with creamy chocolate frosting for the ultimate indulgence.
Calzone
Cheese Calzone
A warm, golden-baked calzone stuffed with a blend of gooey cheeses, offering a perfect savory delight.
Johnny's Appetizers
Signature Pies
Spinach Mushroom Pie
Round Pies
Tyler
Very reliable slice. Both the regular and Sicilian slices were great.
Address
Reviews
Taren
Delicious pizza with a variety of options and fair prices. Definitely recommend!!
Melissa
The pizza was exceptional! It arrived slightly cold, but it was incredibly flavorful.
Christina
Amazing Fresh Mozzarella Margherita Pizza you can taste the freshness of the ingredients View menu
Demian
AVOID! Ordered a pepperoni pizza at 6:37pm and well past 8:00, nothing! Had to call to cancel the order.
Tom
The pizza at Slice is delicious, and the garlic knots are fantastic. If you’re feeling hungry after a night out, this is the perfect spot! Highly recommend!
Laura
The gluten-free crust has a strange texture that feels somewhat chalky or like paper, which was not very enjoyable. Aside from that, the pizza itself was good. View menu
Paolo
Really really good slices! Their plain slice was damn near perfect NY style: Warm, crispy, perfect balance of cheese and sauce. The square slice was awesome too!
Alexis
This pizza is incredible! I’m quite selective about my pizza, but wow, this one is fantastic. I ordered the White Pie with Ricotta, and it was perfectly soft and baked. I highly recommend it!
David
I’ve been coming here for years whenever I am on the Upper West Side or wanting to have pizza in the park. It was one of my favorite pizza places in the city. There are several different pizza places with the same name and signage as this one on 80th and Amsterdam but I believe this is the best. It is a very standard pizza place with usually plenty of seating. I’d say it can be very hot inside the restaurant on a hot day. Always look for the pies that look like they have been made recently as they typically taste the best. I can’t recommend this place more and can’t wait to go back. View menu
Categories
-
Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
-
Lunch Satisfy your midday cravings with our delicious lunch menu. From fresh salads and hearty sandwiches to savory soups and vibrant bowls, each dish is crafted to give you the perfect midday boost. View menu
-
Magpie
-
Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!
Amenities
-
Mastercard
