Phone: +19292394768,+12122282373,+18776326654
Address: 405 Amsterdam Ave, 10024 New York, City of New York, United States
City: City of New York
Menu Dishes: 35
Reviews: 2119
"I'm on a quest to discover the best cookies in NYC, and I definitely got closer with Insomnia Cookies. They offer the kind of cookies I'm after: soft, chewy, flavorful, and with an incredible variety. I really appreciate their late-night hours, especially for those of us with a sweet tooth who tell ourselves we won’t indulge. However, there is a major downside: their delivery range is quite limited, which undermines the whole point of a late-night cookie service. I found myself just outside their delivery zone, but thankfully I could use Uber Eats. If that option weren’t available, I wouldn’t have been able to get the cookies because there's no way I'm walking around at 11 PM just for sweets. The added fees from Uber Eats were a bit disappointing, especially since Insomnia prides itself on late-night deliveries directly to your door. So, Insomnia Cookies, please consider expanding your delivery options. Living in Hell's Kitchen, I believe I should have had access. If you happen to be within their delivery range, I highly recommend giving them a try. They do offer shipping as well, but that doesn’t quite work when you suddenly have a craving that needs immediate satisfaction."
Full menu - 35 options
All prices are estimates on menu.
Dessert
Cookies
Freshly baked cookies with a golden crust and soft center, available in classic chocolate chip or oatmeal raisin.
Brownies
Rich, fudgy brownies packed with chocolatey goodness, perfect for satisfying any sweet craving.
Ice Cream*
Vanilla
Creamy vanilla ice cream with a rich, smooth texture and a classic sweet flavor.
Topping Prices
Extras
Rainbow Sprinkles
Colorful sugar sprinkles that add a fun, sweet crunch to any dessert.
Deals
Entrées
Thursday | Burgers & Beer
Sundae
Walnut
Crunchy walnuts add a rich, earthy flavor to this delightful dish.
Packed To Go
Desserts
Creamy & Delicious Flavors
Toppings & Mix-Ins
Delicious Mixins
Ben & Jerry's
Sweets
Frosting Flavors
Deluxe Cookies
Add Ons
Brownies $3
Kits Para Hacer En Casa
Wiches
Cookie Cake
C.b.c. Original Cravings
Dough Deals
Gourmet Brownies
Double Chocolate Chunk
A rich and decadent cookie loaded with chunks of dark and milk chocolate for a double dose of sweetness.
Theresa
My Carmel salted cookies was a bit hard. Not like the first time. the others were good though
Address
Reviews
Yossi
The red-haired woman at the front was overwhelmed and refused to take any orders. She seemed particularly stressed about a single order of five cookies and was heard using harsh language towards some customers.
Celine
Insomnia cookies smells like heaven. The chocolate chunk cookie is my favorite and it goes well with the chocolate ice cream. One thing I do not like about this location is the fact that they almost never have the bite size chocolate chunk cookies. Why offer that on the menu if you never have it!?
Casey
We ordered online and instead of contacting us that they were out of one of the cookies we ordered they gave us the wrong cookie. When we called about it the woman told us they were out and rudely rushed us off the phone. Last time I ordered from Insomnia my order never arrived. Not thrilled with their service. View menu
Brandy
The cookies are fantastic, but Brandon at the UWS location really needs to improve his customer service skills. I discovered a new spot just a couple of blocks away that offers not only delicious cookies but also excellent customer service. With so many choices available, I prefer to go where the staff is friendly!
Christobel
The cookies are delicious and best enjoyed fresh out of the oven. My personal favorite is the White Chocolate Macadamia cookie. While the prices are a bit high, they are definitely worth it if you have a serious sweet tooth and need to satisfy a craving. A box of six is the perfect way to try a variety of their best offerings. The service is quick and friendly, but just be cautious of getting stuck behind someone new who might not know the names or flavors of the cookies!
Shannel
I have had several frustrating experiences with my orders placed through Uber Eats at this restaurant. There have been times when my order couldn't be fulfilled due to a lack of inventory, and I received no communication about it. When I did manage to contact them, they simply stated that there was no inventory and offered to substitute items that didn't reflect the value I had paid. Unfortunately, Uber Eats also refuses to address issues regarding delivery and refunds because they are not receiving any communication from the restaurant. I'm really unsure about what’s going on here. View menu
Christopher
Who gets ice cream sandwiches at 1:15 AM? This guy and his wife do! If I could give this place 10 stars, I absolutely would! From the freshly baked cookies that are still warm out of the oven to the incredible staff member—Carl, you're a fantastic addition to the Insomnia Cookies team! It was a true pleasure being served by you, and my wife and I will definitely be back to visit you again! Now, about the cookies and ice cream—WOW! If you find yourself on 79th and Amsterdam Avenue, Insomnia Cookies is a must-visit. And if you're a local, they deliver until 3 AM! This place is definitely Cookie Monster approved!
Gardith
This location's deliveries are always problematic. This is the 4th screw up so I'm leaving a review because, cmon. First time, ordered online and the cookies took 2.5 hours to arrive. 2nd time, ordered three different types of cookies and they only sent Sugar. Third time, I ordered 6 pack and they sent 5. Called and they said they'd send one but of course it never arrived. Tonight, they got the cookies right but I ordered two milks and they sent a bottle of water. Water with cookies?? The customer service is trash. Better buy in store where you will know upfront what you're getting (or not) and don't waste your money with delivery. My kids love their cookies but with all the cookie shops ope...
Sara
I'm on a quest to discover the best cookies in NYC, and I definitely got closer with Insomnia Cookies. They offer the kind of cookies I'm after: soft, chewy, flavorful, and with an incredible variety. I really appreciate their late-night hours, especially for those of us with a sweet tooth who tell ourselves we won’t indulge. However, there is a major downside: their delivery range is quite limited, which undermines the whole point of a late-night cookie service. I found myself just outside their delivery zone, but thankfully I could use Uber Eats. If that option weren’t available, I wouldn’t have been able to get the cookies because there's no way I'm walking around at 11 PM just for sweets... View menu
City of New York
New York City is renowned for its diverse culinary scene, featuring classic street foods like hot dogs and pretzels, along with international cuisines from every corner of the globe.
Categories
-
Desserts Delight in our selection of indulgent desserts, from luscious chocolate creations to delicate fruit-infused treats, each crafted to end your meal on a sweet note and leave your taste buds craving for more.
-
American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes. View menu
-
Ice Cream A delightful selection of creamy, handcrafted ice creams with a variety of flavors ranging from classic vanilla and chocolate to unique options like lavender honey and spicy mango, perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth.
-
Chocolate Decadent chocolate treats crafted with rich, high-quality cocoa. Indulge in an array of offerings from silky mousses to molten lava cakes, each designed to captivate your senses and satisfy your sweet cravings.
Amenities
-
Takeout
-
Delivery
- menu
-
Visa Card
- menu
-
Mastercard
