Peterson's - Menu

7690 East 96th Street Fishers, IN 46038, 46256-10ND, Indianapolis, United States

🛍 Wine, Soup, Steak, Seafood

4.4 💬 8128 Reviews
Peterson's

Phone: +13175988863

Address: 7690 East 96th Street Fishers, IN 46038, 46256-10ND, Indianapolis, United States

City: Indianapolis

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 8128

Website: http://www.petersonsrestaurant.com/

"The food was excellent. We opted for the Devour Indy menu. It is important to note that this menu is specially created for Devour Indy, so the presentation was not as impressive as usual. I ordered the 6 oz. Filet, which was delicious, but the vegetables were not up to par and the overall plate presentation was lacking. It seems that when you choose the Devour menu, you may not get the same quality as Peterson's normally offers. However, the steak alone is worth another visit. We plan on returning."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Entrées

Starters

Dessert

Salads

Seafood

Fresh Seafood

Sandwiches

Ribs

Dishes

Baked Potatoes

Beef Dishes

Steaks

Dinner

Sides

Chef Entrees

Taste & Share

For The Table

A La Carte

Extras

Steakhouse Sliders

Bar Menu - Appetizers

Deluxe Sandwich Platters

Finish Here

Mains

Antone Antone

But this five star rating comes at a price..and a nose bleeder.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Happy
Happy

We had a wonderful meal at a corner booth table that was perfect for celebrating my birthday. Our waiter was excellent.


Cullen
Cullen

I can no longer recommend Peterson's, after our last experience thereI took my husband there for his birthday, about a month ago.


Blaise
Blaise

What an amazing experience! It was our anniversary, so we were seated in a booth that was semi-private and not a part of the main dining area. View menu


char
char

This was mine (and my boyfriend's) first time visiting Peterson's. It was a wonderful treat for both of us, and I know we will be back in the future!


JavanC
JavanC

Excellent date night at Peterson's. Everything was great from the service from Coy, our server to the appetizers, to the entree, to the desert. Looking forward to the next time.


BarryA
BarryA

My wife and I visited for the first time during Indulge Indy. The seating felt private. Great environment, amazing food from appetizer through dessert and I can’t say enough about the steak! Will definitely go back! View menu


CathyS
CathyS

We celebrated our 40th anniversary at this restaurant and had a fantastic experience. Our former classmate Coy Tipton provided exceptional service - he was kind, funny, attentive, but not overwhelming. It was just perfect.


HowardK
HowardK

I realize we were here for Devour Indy, But the salad was small as was the cheesecake. We were informed that we had received the last Tequila Mockingbird as they had run out of ingredients. Don’t get me wrong the meal was fine, but if you are using Devour as a vehicle to gain new customers, treat them as everyday guest not someone on the cheap.


KevinT
KevinT

The food was excellent. We opted for the Devour Indy menu. It is important to note that this menu is specially created for Devour Indy, so the presentation was not as impressive as usual. I ordered the 6 oz. Filet, which was delicious, but the vegetables were not up to par and the overall plate presentation was lacking. It seems that when you choose the Devour menu, you may not get the same quality as Peterson's normally offers. However, the steak alone is worth another visit. We plan on returning. View menu

Indianapolis

Indianapolis

Indianapolis, known for the Indy 500, offers Midwestern comfort food, with staples like pork tenderloin sandwiches and sugar cream pie, reflecting its rich cultural and culinary heritage.

Categories

  • Wine A curated selection of fine wines from around the world, offering rich reds, crisp whites, and elegant rosés to pair perfectly with your meal. Savor each bottle's unique aroma, flavor, and complexity.
  • Soup Warm and comforting soups to nourish your soul. Choose from a variety of flavorful broths and hearty ingredients, perfect for a simple appetizer or a satisfying meal on a chilly day. View menu
  • Steak Savor prime cuts of juicy, tender steaks, expertly grilled to perfection. Each bite offers a burst of flavor, served with classic sides and delectable sauces to enhance your dining experience.
  • Seafood Dive into the freshest catches of the sea with our seafood selection, featuring exquisite dishes prepared with high-quality fish and shellfish. Savor the flavors of the ocean in every bite!

Amenities

  • Beer
  • Wine
  • menu
  • Amex
  • menu
  • Takeout

Similar Restaurants

Tony's Of Indianapolis

Tony's Of Indianapolis

110 W Washington StreetIN 462043431, Indianapolis, United States

Menu • Seafood • Italian • Steakhouse • Bar-lounge


"My son was in from California so we wanted to take him to Tony’s. We have been before and think highly of the restaurant. Positives: Calamari, wedge, steaks and pasta were very good.Positives: My mother who is very picky loved her steak although she did send it back because it was not hot when it came to the table. She still raved about it even after that. That is really something.Negatives: Lobster tail was so over cooked it came out all curled up. It took me a minute to even figure it out. I sent it back. They asked if I wanted another one. I said “no”. I was getting full anyway so no reason to add another to the bill since they obviously do not know how to cook it. Suggestion if you don’t know how to cook it then take it off of the menuNegative: Preoccupied waiter. I would have gotten a glass of wine with dinner. Waiter never asked. I have been to Tony’s before and have had very attentive waiters. Not this time.Negative: Not Tony’s fault but a large table by us were drunk and very loud. Negative: I have no desire to come back. Their steaks are very good but if you can’t cook a lobster tail it puts Tony’s as a great steakhouse in Indy at the bottom of the list. Their credibility is gone to me. Suggestion: Bringing a nice piece of desert to the table on the house would have been a nice gesture and then I may have wanted to come back. They had a full house so a party of was probably not a priority"

Ali'i Poke

Ali'i Poke

910 W 10th St Ste 4, Indianapolis, IN 46202, United States

Menu • Poke • Pizza • Sushi • Fusion


"Inside, you’ll find seating at tables and the bar, along with a pleasant patio area that overlooks the sidewalk. They also have a self-serve water station in the front. Unfortunately, the cleanliness of the place left much to be desired. I chose to sit at the bar, and it appeared to have not been wiped down all day. The floor was quite dirty as well. The staff did what was necessary, but seemed to lack enthusiasm. You can customize your own bowl or select one of their signature options. Feeling adventurous, I decided to create my own bowl. Regardless of your choice, you start with a base. I opted for traditional sushi rice over brown rice and spring mix salad. Next, I had to select a protein. The size of your bowl determines how many scoops you receive. The regular size allows for two scoops, so I chose one scoop of spicy tuna and one of marinated salmon, although options like octopus, tofu, and shrimp are also available. After that, you can add various toppings and sauces. I have to admit, my bowl was quite tasty and packed with protein. The atmosphere was relaxed, with music playing softly in the background. Unlike the other location I've visited, this one doesn't offer shaved ice, just poke. Overall, I found this place to be just average compared to other locations I've tried, which is why I’m giving it a 3-star rating. The poke was decent, but everything else felt pretty standard at best."