Maggie's - Menu

The Copper Trout

➤ 250 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, USA, BAYFIELD, United States

Menu • Pizza • Cakes • Casual • Italian

---

"I really wanted to like this place. After reading all the positive reviews, we decided to give it a try. However, it was a big mistake. We arrived at 5:30pm and were told there would be an hour wait, which is understandable for a popular restaurant. However, the wait ended up being much longer. The reason for the delay was that they had given us a buzzer for our table, but they never wrote our name down. We only found out about this after waiting on their outdoor patio for an hour, buying drinks at the bar, and then checking with the hostess at 6:30pm, who informed us that they had lost our name completely. It was only after a kind customer outside our party mentioned to the hostess that we were waiting with drinks and a buzzer on the patio that they realized their mistake. They did not have a table ready for us in the dining area, so they offered us a drink at the bar. We assumed it would be comped due to the inconvenience, but we had to pay full price. After waiting another 15-20 minutes, we finally got a table. Despite the mix-up, the food was excellent. Just make sure to double-check that your name is on the list, even if you have their restaurant buzzer."

Manypenny Bistro

➤ 201 Manypenny Ave, Bayfield, USA, BAYFIELD, United States

Menu • Pizza • Vegan • American • Vegetarian

---

"We visited this restaurant for Sunday brunch and absolutely loved it! Everything was delicious and fresh, and our waitress Shana was fantastic. This was the fourth restaurant we tried during our stay in Bayfield, and it was the only one that provided excellent service. If we weren't leaving the next day, we definitely would have eaten there again. My friend ordered the mushroom and cheese omelette, which was massive and fluffy. I had the grilled badger, a scrambled egg and ham breakfast sandwich on cranberry wild rice bread, served with a special sauce for dipping or spreading. We both had what they call toss potatoes, which were perfectly seasoned and cooked home fries. This was the best meal we had in Bayfield!"

The Deck

➤ 20 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, USA, BAYFIELD, United States

Menu • Wine • Coffee • American • Breakfast

---

"This is probably one of the nicest hotels I have stayed at in Bayfield! For reference, I have stayed in a lot of hotels in the Bayfield area over the years, and I have to say this was the nicest one yet. It is a little expensive, but in my opinion it was worth it! We booked one of the jacuzzi rooms for a weekend (which of course is more expensive than a regular one) and I am so glad we did. The jacuzzi was so relaxing and the room itself was comfortable. The staff were super nice and accommodating. Although we didn’t need anything during our stay, I’m positive it would have been taken care of for us. The parking is spacious and you get “permits” for your stay so that it ensures all customers get parking. It is in such a convenient location because everything is within walking distance. We were deciding between this one and another location and I am glad we chose this hotel because of it being so convenient to stay in the parking lot and just walk where we needed to go without stressing over parking. The only downside is that there is no continental breakfast. They do have the restaurant attached which we had dinner at and it was delicious. Also, they have vending machines where you can purchase snack. However, for the price we paid, I will say the main con I had here was not being able to have anything included for breakfast, even if it was something simple or some discount for purchasing a room at their hotel. Thankfully there are quite a few options to choose from for breakfast (including the attached restaurant), and I know there aren’t a whole lot of other hotels in Bayfield that actually provide breakfast either. So unfortunately this is something that is hard to come by in general if you want to stay in Bayfield (unless you go to the bed and breakfasts or stay in Ashland). Overall I am glad we came. I had a lot of fun and I would love to come back soon!"

Greunke's First Street Inn Dining

➤ 17 Rittenhouse Avenue, Bayfield, 54814, United States Of America, BAYFIELD

Menu • Pizza • Cakes • American • Breakfast

---

"The food at the restaurant was delicious, but the service was slow. Despite this, the staff was very polite and courteous with a smile. There was no requirement to wear a face mask. The path to the ladies' bathroom was a bit narrow, which may be difficult for those who are claustrophobic. The restaurant had a lot of memorabilia on the walls, such as items related to Elvis Presley and Marilyn Monroe. It was very busy when we visited at 11:30am on July 4th. There was an ice cream stand near the parking lot. Although there was a patio, it was closed. The menu was limited, as they had already run out of some items. Some people in our group enjoyed the Reuben cheeseburger, while the trout was good but could use more seasoning when boiled. There was also an option for deep-fried trout. Fish hearts were available on the menu for those interested. Unfortunately, the truck hadn't come in, so none of us received the coleslaw that was supposed to come with our meals."

Pier Plaza

➤ 1 Rittenhouse Avenue, Bayfield, 54814, United States Of America, BAYFIELD

Menu • Pizza • Vegan • Seafood • American

---

"We were visiting the area (Mon-Tues) and needed a place to eat supper. We thought we were walking into The Pickled Herring but I think that's a lounge connected to the Pier Plaza restaurant. We entered from Front Street, the patio side but the hostess stand is on Rittenhouse. The place was full but we were sat quickly. Our waiter greeted us but said it'd be a little bit before he took our order, which was fine because we had to look over the menu. When he returned, I ordered Sharon's Favorite sandwich with homemade potato chips and my sister got the Beef and Portobella and Swiss burger. My chicken sandwich was good. You can't go wrong with guacamole and bacon. The homemade potato chips were eh. No seasoning. Just tasted like burnt potato chips. My sister said the mushroom burger was good (but Wahlburgers mushroom burger was better). She ordered fries though. They were crisp and golden brown, not much potato though. The best part of the meal was the dill pickle spear! It was juicy, crisp and packed a punch! Not all pickles do that (Jimmy John's comes close) and I'd consider this one of my favorites. The menu had Lake Superior fun facts so that was interesting to read while we were waiting for our food to come. We were two of the younger people here. It made me wonder who everyone was. Were they locals or retired folks weekday vacationing like us? Lots of white hair beards."